Pennsylvania isn’t anywhere near the “high seas” trafficked by legendary swashbuckling pirates, but what kid didn’t grow up with dreams of finding mysterious maps and buried chests of gold? We probably won’t find a sunken Spanish galleon in the Allegheny River anytime soon, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t hidden treasure out there to keep our childhood imaginations alive. In fact, there most certainly IS a such thing as lost treasure in PA.

Pennsylvania has several tales of lost loot throughout history. Even if you aren’t ready to grab a pickaxe and comb the forests for robbers’ gold, the state has plenty of other small treasures to uncover: American Indian artifacts and arrowheads, Ice Age fossils, gemstones, and Civil War bullets are discovered quite frequently…but we couldn’t help but indulge our imagination with some of the more colorful legends. Here are 7 great ones that might just lead you to a fantastic fortune…or at least inspire some excellent bedtime stories.

Are you ready to go for a treasure hunt in PA? Hundreds of individual coins as well as silver and gold pieces have turned up across the state numerous times, but none of the above-mentioned historical hoards have ever been fully excavated. Whether or not the secret stashes have been raided by now, it’s fun to imagine stumbling across a discovery like these! Have you ever found long-lost treasures? Where should we start digging?! Tell us about your fantastic finds – small or large – in the comments!

If you can’t get enough of all the amazingness that is life in Pennsylvania, you’ll love some of our most amazing landmarks. Embark upon an amazing landmarks road trip in PA to experience our little state at its best.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

More to Explore

Lost Treasure in PA

  1. Is there such a thing as lost treasure in Pennsylvania?  

Supposedly, yes. There are numerous sites said to contain hidden or otherwise lost loot and treasures from past excursions of who-knows-who. They say there are numerous caches of gold, silver, cash, and more that were once buried for safekeeping that eventually was lost when the owner either died or forgot where they buried it. The prospect of digging up some treasure in PA sure is a fun one, and we like to think about what would happen if we found some!  

2. What are some infamous lost treasures in Pennsylvania? 

With buried treasures come the tales of how they were lost in the first place. Some of the (alleged) lost treasures in Pennsylvania worth researching are ones like: 

  • $30,000 worth of gold coins said to be King George ll’s Lost Plunder 
  • Captain Blackbeard’s Lost Silver, said to be $1.5 million worth of silver bars 
  • The hidden fortunes of the Doan Boys Gang, said to be $2 million at least 
  • The epic treasure along the shores of Potato Creek – an incredible $5 million in gold and silver bouillon 


3. Where are some of the best places to go metal detecting in Pennsylvania?  

Can’t get enough of looking for your own buried treasure? You might want to try metal detecting! Some of the best places to go metal detecting in Pennsylvania include:  

  • Canoe Creek State Park 

Explore Pennsylvania