Love Nantucket? Try This Similar Spot in Rhode Island

Watch Hill, Rhode Island, first caught my attention as a quieter, more affordable alternative to Nantucket. The more I looked into it, the more it seemed like a hidden gem. It has all the coastal charm you’d expect from a New England getaway: beautiful beaches, historic architecture, and plenty of fresh seafood, but without the hefty price tag or summer crowds. It’s the kind of coastal town that quietly impresses, and honestly, it’s moved straight to the top of my travel list because of this.

​Tucked into the southwestern corner of Rhode Island, Watch Hill is a neighborhood in the town of Westerly, offering the same picturesque scenery and classic seaside appeal as Nantucket. But here, you don’t need to book a ferry in advance or splurge on a hotel to enjoy it.

Bay Street is the neighborhood’s main strip, lined with boutique shops and casual seafood spots. It has a relaxed, coastal energy that feels similar to Nantucket’s Main Street. One standout is the Flying Horse Carousel, the oldest operating merry-go-round in the country. It brings a nostalgic charm that rivals a visit to Nantucket’s Whaling Museum.

If beach time is a priority, East Beach is a must-see. This three-mile stretch faces the Atlantic and delivers wide-open views and steady waves. Even during the busy season, you won’t be packed in elbow-to-elbow—there’s room to breathe, spread out your towel, and relax.

Architecture fans will appreciate the area’s shingled beach houses and turn-of-the-century cottages. They mirror Nantucket’s iconic look, and places like the Ocean House are prime examples. This grand Victorian-era hotel sits on a bluff with sweeping ocean views. It has that old-school luxury you might associate with the White Elephant—but with arguably more dramatic scenery.

Food-wise, Watch Hill doesn’t hold back. Lobster rolls, clam cakes, chowder—you’ll find all the staples here, often at better prices than on the island. The seafood shacks and casual restaurants keep things simple and fresh. Try the Olympia Tea Room, a longtime favorite for delicious seafood and a cocktail at sunset. It’s the type of place where locals are friendly and unhurried, happy to chat or share a few recommendations, often with a story or two about the area’s maritime roots.

It’s true that Watch Hill doesn’t have Nantucket’s expansive dune systems, but it makes up for it with coastal trails and the Napatree Point Conservation Area. This preserved stretch of beach is quiet, scenic, and great for birdwatching or just walking along the shoreline.

For families, Watch Hill offers more than just beautiful beaches. Kids can hunt for treasures in tide pools, enjoy ice cream at St. Clair Annex (a local favorite since 1887), and explore the Watch Hill Lighthouse.

And while Watch Hill has its fair share of notable visitors—Taylor Swift’s summer home is perched on the bluff—it still feels grounded. There’s no big scene, no fuss, just an easygoing pace that makes it feel special in a different way.

The best time to visit is from late spring to early fall, though summer weekends can get busy. Unlike Nantucket, which often books up months in advance, Watch Hill is more accommodating for spontaneous trips. If you’re after a New England coastal escape that doesn’t require too much effort or expense, Watch Hill is worth considering. The views are just as stunning, the vibe is just as timeless, and the whole trip feels much more doable.

If you’re planning a visit, staying at the Ocean House will give you the ultimate seaside experience, allowing you to unwind and truly soak in the beauty of the area. For more inspiration, check out this one-day Rhode Island route that perfectly blends coastal and natural views, helping you make the most of your time in the Ocean State.