Peanut butter is a staple in most pantries, beloved by generations of Americans. While around for centuries, peanut butter as we know it got its start in 1884 and was perfected in the 1920s by brands including Peter Pan and Skippy (Jif came about in 1955). The United States is a leading exporter of peanut butter and itself consumes $800 million of peanut butter annually. It’s something that we’re all familiar with, but it’s anything but basic…especially at this amazing New Jersey shop!

Related Stories

This Bargain Hunters Road Trip Will Take You To The Best Thrift Stores In New Jersey

This Bargain Hunters Road Trip Will Take You To The Best Thrift Stores In New Jersey

One Trip To This Pickle Shop In New Jersey And You’ll Relish It Forever

One Trip To This Pickle Shop In New Jersey And You’ll Relish It Forever

New Jersey's Most Anticipated Grocery Store, Stew Leonard's, Is Opening This Month

New Jersey's Most Anticipated Grocery Store, Stew Leonard's, Is Opening This Month

Sound wonderful? We think so! You can find the Cape May Peanut Butter Co. at 516 Carpenter Lane, Cape May. Closer to the Atlantic City area? Check out their sister store at 615 E Moss Mill Road, Absecon. You can also check out their website (they ship!) by clicking here. Another food that goes great with peanut butter? Chocolate! Check out a New Jersey Chocolate Lover’s Road Trip by clicking here.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Explore New Jersey