A few days ago I wrote an article about unique restaurants in Indiana. I do read the comments in these articles and the comments told me one thing, my readers definitely wanted a follow-up article, and they had some suggestions. I took these suggestions into account, did a little research, and created a second list of restaurants in Indiana that are sure to give you a unique experience.

1. Gray Brothers Cafeteria (Mooresville)
Gray Bros. Cafeteria, 555 S Indiana St, Mooresville, IN 46158, USA
Gray Brother’s Cafeteria / Facebook
Gary Brothers Cafeteria / Facebook
With a menu that varies day to day, Gray Brothers Cafeteria is definitely unique. Their strawberry pie and fried chicken are a favorite amongst the diners. Gray Brothers Cafeteria offers dine-in, carryout, catering, and delivery! They have been a favorite in Mooresville since 1944. They're frequently hailed as one of the best restaurants in Indiana.
2. The Schnitzelbank Restaurant
Schnitzelbank, 393 Third Ave, Jasper, IN 47546, USA
David Riggleman / Google Maps
Schnitzelbank Restaurant Jasper / Facebook
The Schnitzelbank Restaurant features an "Olde World" atmosphere. With a variety of platters ranging from local favorites to classic German food and a scrumptious salad bar, you just can't go wrong. They offer catering for any special event. This restaurant also has a gift shop for those of you who want a remembrance of your time there. This is such a unique dining experience in Indiana!
3. TC's Restaurant and Tavern (Battle Ground)
TC's Restaurant & Tavern, 109 N Railroad St, Battle Ground, IN 47920, USA
Karrie62/ tripadvisor.com
TC’s is a small town favorite! With a great staff and their amazing ribs and sandwiches, TC’s is always busy but able to give you the meal of your life. The parking and seating can be limited so this restaurant is one that requires you to arrive early if you want to beat the rush. We love this unique dining experience in Indiana!
4. Sylvia's Brick Oven & Columbia Ballroom (Lafayette) (Permanently Closed.)
tripadvisor.com
Both pictures are from tripadvisor.com.
Sylvia’s Brick Oven & Columbia Ballroom features casual dining at its finest. With amazing cannolis for dessert and spaghetti and meatballs for supper (or even a great sandwich and chips), you can't go wrong. They offer dine-in and carry out every day all day long. They feature a ballroom for hosting all of your special events too!
5. Top Notch Bar (Brookston)
Top Notch Bar, 113 E 3rd St, Brookston, IN 47923, USA
Dave A / tripadvisor.com
Definitely unique, Top Notch Bar is not quite like all the others. You must be 21 years of age to dine here. Beer and sandwiches, even steaks, are available here at Top Notch Bar. The bartender tends to be a jokester, so prepare to have fun and be entertained. With a simple menu and friendly staff, it doesn't take long to form an opinion about Top Notch Bar. Easily one of the best restaurants in Indiana. You could say it's... top notch.

Related Stories

6 Oddball Restaurants In Indiana That Will Change The Way You Think Of Eating Out

6 Oddball Restaurants In Indiana That Will Change The Way You Think Of Eating Out

 The Tea Parties At This Magical Tea House In Indiana Will Transport You Straight Into A Fairy Tale

The Tea Parties At This Magical Tea House In Indiana Will Transport You Straight Into A Fairy Tale

 6 Restaurants In Indiana With The Most Amazing Waterfront Dining

6 Restaurants In Indiana With The Most Amazing Waterfront Dining
6. The Log Inn (Haubstadt)
The Log Inn, 12491 County Rd 200 E, Haubstadt, IN 47639, USA
The_RVQueen / TripAdvisor
Log Inn is noted as the oldest restaurant in Indiana. It was built in 1825. This is one restaurant that's definitely worth driving to as even Abraham Lincoln once stopped here in November of 1844. Log Inn has a unique menu including Family Style Dinners and A La Carte. This place in most definitely as unique as it's original! This Indiana restaurant has so much history!
7. Mayberry Cafe (Danville)
Mayberry Cafe, 78 W Main St, Danville, IN 46122, USA
tripadvisor.com
Mayberry Café has a home cooked feel to it. A unique place, the Mayberry Café is a step back into time and offers a setting like that of the Andy Griffin show! There are two floors and this café seats up to 150 guests! The Mayberry Café offers dine in, catering, and carryout. We think this is such a cool restaurant in Indiana.
8. Aladdin Pita (Merrillville)
Aladdin Pita, 3750 W 80th Ln, Merrillville, IN 46410, USA
francescamy / tripadvisor.com
Considered a fine dining restaurant, Aladdin Pita is definitely a place to stop by and enjoy some Middle Eastern Cuisine! Aladdin Pita is fairly priced and offers several varieties of food and drink. One of our favorite Indiana restaurants serving Middle Eastern cuisine!
9. Zydeco's Cajun (Mooresville)
Zydeco's, 11 E Main St, Mooresville, IN 46158, USA
Zydeco's Cajun / Facebook
Zydeco’s Cajun is a fun place to eat. With their Cajun menu it's hard to pick favorites. There's a New Orleans feel to the whole place. With beads and posters on their brick walls, Zydeco’s gives that Louisiana feel to it. It's definitely one of the more unique restaurants in Indiana!
10. Ivanhoe's Drive In (Upland)
Ivanhoes Drive, Ivanhoes Dr, Upland, IN 46989, USA
Jeff Belknap / Google Maps
Rebecca Burcroff / Google Maps
If you're looking for a fun place to sit and eat, Ivanhoe’s is the place to go. Ivanhoe’s is famous for its variety of flavors of shakes and ice cream. having over 100 to choose from. Their menu is simple and anything you get will be well worth the visit! Ivanhoe's Drive In is a unique dining experience in Indiana.
11. Papa’s (Culver)
Papa's, 824 N Lake Shore Dr, Culver, IN 46511, USA
Papa’s / Facebook
Papa’s / Facebook
If you're looking for a great pizza place, Papa’s is it! Papa’s is family owned and operated. They offer more than just pizzas including hand cut steaks and fresh seafood. With 30 regional draft beers available and an extensive wine list you cannot go wrong. Papa's is easily one of the best restaurants in Indiana!

Do you feel more satisfied now with your choices? Do you have any other places to eat in Indiana that you really think everyone should know about? Did your favorite restaurant make the unique restaurants in Indiana list? Please share with me in the comments!

Looking for even MORE great restaurants in Indiana? Check out this list of Indiana restaurants that give you an unforgettable dining experience!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Unique Restaurants In Indiana

Megan McDonald | January 27, 2023

What food item is Indiana known for?

Indiana is known for its sugar cream pie! It’s also famous for its persimmon pudding, corn on the cob, pork tenderloin sandwiches, and the most popular fast food joint in the state is Five Guys. Indiana is well-known for its love of good food.

What food chain restaurant started in Indiana?

Indiana had a couple of food chain restaurants start in the state. It is home to Wendy’s, Kentucky Fried Chicken, and Burger Chef, among others. If you love fried chicken, Indiana does, too. Here are some of our favorite places to get fried chicken in Indiana:

 

What is the most unique restaurant in Indiana?

The most unique restaurant in Indiana is The Schnitzelbank Restaurant. This restaurant features an “Olde World” atmosphere. With a variety of platters ranging from local favorites to classic German food and a delicious salad bar, there is something for everyone.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana

Featured Addresses
Indiana, USA