10 Unassuming Restaurants To Add To Your Pennsylvania Dining Bucket List

Discover 10 unassuming restaurants in Pennsylvania that offer exceptional dining experiences despite their simple exteriors.

Remember our teachers and parents telling us we can't judge a book by its cover? Well, the following 10 unassuming restaurants in Pennsylvania pretty much prove that old saying true. The simple exteriors of these cozy Pennsylvania restaurants give little clue to the delicious dining experience that awaits within.

1. Heisey's Diner – Lebanon

A neighborhood staple since 1968, Heisey's Diner's exterior looks as though it's stepped straight out of the past. Serving traditional diner food, this eatery is not to be missed. Heisey's Diner is located at 1740 PA-72. To learn more, visit the official website for Heisey's Diner in Lebanon.

2. Ernie's Texas Lunch – Gettysburg

Grab a bite to eat at Ernie's Texas Lunch where you'll step back in time to the 1930s. The long-standing Pennsylvania restaurant, which opened in the early 20th century, is located at 58 Chambersburg Street. Eating here is a treat for the senses! Visit the Facebook page for Ernie's Texas Lunch to learn more.

3. Kosta's Restaurant – Ebensburg

Pull up a chair and enjoy a delightful meal at Kosta's Restaurant. The cozy restaurant, located at 3135 New Germany Rd #5, features a breakfast, a lunch, and a dinner menu. No matter when you visit, you'll be blown away by their delicious dishes. Visit the official website for Kosta's Restaurant to learn more.

4. Inlow's Drive-In – Duncansville

Step back through the pages of time when you visit Inlow's Drive In, known for its footlong hotdogs topped with whatever the diner wants. Inlow's Drive In, located at 285 Inlows Road, features traditional diner food, including hotdogs, burgers, hoagies, and fries. It's American comfort food at its finest! Visit the Facebook page for Inlow's Drive-In to learn more.

5. The Korner Restaurant – Rimbersburg

Enjoy at meal at The Korner Restaurant, located at 626 Lawsonham Road, where you can order such delicious dishes as hot roast beef, chicken planks, and apple pie for dessert. Visit the official Facebook page for The Korner Restaurant to learn more.

6. Lincoln Diner – Gettysburg

Raise your milkshake - peanut butter or black raspberry - in a toast any time of the day or the night at Lincoln Diner, open 24 hours a day. The Lincoln Diner, which serves traditional diner food, is located at 32 Carlisle Street. Check them out -- your sweet tooth will thank you. Visit the official website for Lincoln Diner to learn more.

7. Laurel's Hometown Cafe – Honesdale

Nestled among a row of buildings on Main Street in Honesdale, Laurel's Hometown Cafe is easy to miss. But, it's a quaint spot you definitely want to stop by for lunch or dinner. This charming eatery is located at 526 Main Street. To learn more, visit the official Facebook page for Laurel's Hometown Cafe.

8. Heritage Hoagies – Huntingdon Valley

Sometimes nothing hits the spot like a hoagie topped with fresh meats, cheeses, and other condiments. Heritage Hoagies hits the spot. The unassuming hoagie spot is located at 2447 Huntingdon Pike. To learn more, visit the official website for Heritage Hoagies.

9. Tavern in the Wall – Aspinwall

A simple exterior gives little clue to the experience diners will enjoy when they walk through the door at The Tavern in the Wall at 211 Commercial Avenue. Serving traditional tavern food - from burgers to barbecue - the Tavern in the Wall has something for everyone. To learn more, visit the official website for Tavern in the Wall.

10. Big Jim's Restaurant and Bar– Pittsburgh

Diners, in search of good food and a friendly atmosphere, have been flocking to Big Jim's, 201 Saline Street, since the mid-1970s. A simple, unpretentious sign announces the popular restaurant's presence. You can't miss it! To learn more, visit the official website for Big Jim's Restaurant and Bar.

How many of these unassuming restaurants in Pennsylvania have you already visited? Are there others - like these Pennsylvania restaurants - that you think should have also made the list? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below!

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest updates and news

All Stories