The Hidden Attraction in Arizona That People Still Seek Out to This Day

Tonto National Forest is no stranger to mystery and urban legends, and is home to some of the best hidden attractions in Arizona. In fact, legend has it that many of the caves in the forest are gateways to the underworld. While we can’t confirm (or deny) these rumors, we can tell you that there is a hidden cave that locals keep going back to, even though the hike is challenging. Located along the Bob Bear Trail, previously known as Fossil Springs Trail, is Fossil Creek Cave. Just five miles west of the mountain town of Strawberry, you’ll need to put in some work to see this hidden gem in Arizona for yourself. That said, we think this cave surrounded by its pretty, turquoise pool is worth every step.    

The Story Behind This Hidden Cave and Swimming Hole

The name Fossil Creek Cave makes me wonder if this area is a site of an underground world where an enormous number of dinosaur fossils were found. That assumption couldn’t be further from the truth. No fossilized animals were discovered here. Instead, the name comes from Fossil Springs, which has a large amount of calcium carbonate deposits that bind to decaying vegetation, causing them to calcify and resemble fossils. 

Moreover, the minerals carved the caves and rock outcroppings in the area, resulting in some unique formations. Plus, the calcium carbonate is the reason for the turquoise-blue waters. So, although there is no mysterious dinosaur world here, you’ll be exploring one of the most unique places in Arizona. Unfortunately, a few years ago, a major fire devastated the area, resulting in a temporary closure. On your hike, you’ll even see the burned trees that were left behind. Now that the trail is open, you’ll find locals in the know hiking the trail and cooling off in the cool, crystal-clear pools.  

Why People Still Visit Today

AllTrails lists the Bob Bear Trail as hard, but the Forest Service marks it as “strenuous” and mentions that it’s “not for the faint of heart.” Even with the warning signs at the trailhead about the hundreds of people who didn’t survive the hike, it doesn’t stop the true adventure-seekers looking for a one-of-a-kind experience from taking on this challenge. If you’re a beginner hiker or you’re not used to the rugged terrain or brutal weather in Arizona, this might not be the hike for you. Opt for the easier hike to see the Soldiers Pass Cave in Sedona instead.

Recently, the Bob Bear Trail became famous because (you probably guessed it), social media, and with the new buzz, the parking lot fills up pretty quickly. More than that, this is no ordinary outdoor adventure. Aside from the challenge of the hike, there is so much along this trail.

You’ll see a flowing spring, a stunning waterfall with a swimming hole, and views of mesas in the distance. This waterfall is a great place to stop before you make your way to the hidden cave. At the small entrance of the cave, you’ll need to swim through rushing waters to get into the hidden oasis. That is a lot of different adventures all along this 8-mile out-and-back hike inside the forest.

What to Know Before You Go

As mentioned before, this is not a hike for beginners, and leave the kids and dogs at home, especially in the warmer months. Because the temperatures can hit triple digits in the summer, we don’t recommend hiking the trail then. However, if you do, start early and bring more water than you need. Another reason to skip the summer months? A mandatory permit is required between April 1 and October 1, and you’ll need to make reservations a month in advance, meaning it will take some extra planning to access the area during that time. 

There are rocky and slippery sections, so sturdy shoes are a must. The trek to the cave starts out easy on a narrow downhill route. But keep in mind, there’s a 1,500 elevation gain, and it’s all uphill coming back on a path with little to no shade. Take extra breaks if needed.

Near the falls and grotto, the area is overgrown and not well-maintained, so wear long sleeves and pants for extra protection. Of course, if you plan to swim, which we recommend you do, bring a bathing suit and don’t forget your sunscreen. Some people bring tubes to float in, so if you have one, don’t leave it behind. Pack enough snacks, as you’ll want to stay and play for a while.  

Whether you live in the area or are just visiting, plan a trip to this waterfall and cave to experience one of Arizona’s unique gems. It’s the kind of place that reminds us the Grand Canyon State has more to offer than its iconic red rock landscape.     

Be sure to visit the Forest Service website to learn more about this secret local spot. And for more adventure beyond Arizona, check out these underrated destinations across the U.S. They include canyons, waterfalls, beautiful islands, and even a site where a meteor left a massive crater.