let us do the work

Effortlessly plan your next adventure with AI
FoodBakeries & Dessert

This Country Store In New York Sells The Most Amazing Homemade Fudge You’ll Ever Try

Kelly’s Country Store in Grand Island, New York, is renowned for its exceptional homemade fudge and has been a beloved family-run business since 1962.

Published Dec 7, 2022

Written by 

Christy Articola

If you're on the hunt for the best fudge in New York, we found it for you! Kelly's Country Store is a candy store in Grand Island that has been in business since 1962. The chocolates and candies sold at Kelly's are homemade and the business has been in the same family for four generations. People come from all over the area, the state, and the country to buy and enjoy Kelly's treats. Everything at Kelly's is good, but the fudge is truly out of this world. Read on to learn more about this amazing place and its fudge.

Walter and Grace Kelly began their business by selling penny candy at festivals in the 1950s. Soon, everyone wanted to know where to find their store, so they traded their Buffalo home plus one dollar for their first location.

A red barn-style country store with a sloped roof, pumpkins outside, and hay bales in front.
Management/Facebook

Kelly's Country Store has been a big hit ever since. The cases of chocolates are always full and are very mouthwatering.

A display case filled with various types of chocolates and confections, showcasing an array of shapes and flavors.
Management/Facebook

The jarred candy is always well-stocked, too!

A colorful display of candy jars filled with various sweets in a vintage candy shop.
Management/Facebook

Kelly's creates wonderful gift options for every holiday.

A box of assorted chocolates with a shiny red gift box, surrounded by pink heart decorations on a light tablecloth.
Management/Facebook

But the one thing that *everybody* raves about is Kelly's fudge. It's perfect.

Three pieces of fudge: one chocolate with nuts, one chocolate layer, and one creamy beige fudge, displayed on red boxes.
Management/Facebook

This fudge is not only tasty, but it's beautiful to look at, too.

A rectangular chocolate dessert bar on a piece of parchment paper, resting on a wooden surface.
Management/Facebook

Kelly's offers a variety of different flavors of fudge. Perhaps you'd like to try some chocolate peanut butter fudge?

A display of chocolate peanut butter fudge in a clear container at Kelly's Country Store.
Management/Facebook

Or maybe you'd just like some plain peanut butter fudge?

A display of peanut butter fudge blocks in a glass case at Kelly's Country Store.
Management/Facebook

The chocolate walnut fudge melts in your mouth every time.

A close-up of stacked chocolate fudge bars with nuts, resting on a tray lined with parchment paper.
Management/Facebook

Maple fudge is also scrumptious. In addition to the flavors shown here, Kelly's also makes and sells chocolate and vanilla fudge, too.

A display of maple fudge in a glass case at Kelly's Country Store, with a sign indicating its establishment in 1962.
v

If you like Kelly's fudge, then you'll also love Kelly's sponge candy. You should stop by Kelly's Country Store as soon as possible and load up on candy, chocolates, and most of all - FUDGE!

A white dish filled with assorted chocolate-covered candies, varying in shape and size, on a wooden surface.
Management/Facebook

Kelly's Country Store in Grand Island is really something special. Everything about it is tasty and wonderful, but you'll especially like the fudge. Plan a trip to this old-time candy factory and store today. You'll be glad that you did and you'll surely want to come back time and time again for more!

Looking for more candy shops to satisfy your sweet tooth? Check out this list for more: These 11 Candy Shops In New York Will Make Your Sweet Tooth Explode

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest updates and news

All Stories

Trips & Routes
Unique Trips

The 11 Most Spectacular Tree Tunnel Drives in America

Some roads exist just to get you somewhere else. These eleven don't, and that's exactly the point.

by Marisa Roman
on Jul 21
Cypress tree tunnel at Point Reyes, California, USA
Trips & Routes
Small Towns

The 17 Most Charming Hidden Towns You’ve Never Heard Of Across the U.S.

Every state hides at least one town this good, and locals would rather keep it that way. We found 17 of them, from quiet river towns to desert outposts, so you can get there before everyone else does.

by Marisa Roman
on Jul 21
Dahlonega, Georgia aerial view, one of the most charming hidden towns in the U.S.
Trips & Routes
Travel Preparation & Advice

The Regional Airports Across America With the Most and Least Expensive Airfare (2026 Rankings)

Only In Your State used government data to compare average airfare costs for departing flights at more than 100 of America’s regional airports to find where travelers get the most bang for their buck.

by Josh Koebert
on Jul 21
ATI cargo Boeing 767 aircraft and air traffic control tower, SeaTac Seattle, USA
Trips & Routes

Endless Outdoor Adventures Await in These 6 Small Towns in Oklahoma

Check out the most outdoorsy towns in Oklahoma, from hiking and paddling destinations to charming communities surrounded by natural beauty.

by Christy Articola
on Jul 21
The bow of a kayak is shown on a river with thick forest on both sides.
Nature

The Most Beautiful Lake in Missouri That Most People Have Never Heard Of

Tucked away and often overlooked, this stunning lake in Missouri offers incredible views and peaceful surroundings. Here’s why it’s worth the trip.

by Jacki Mick
on Jul 21
White sailboats drifting on Fellows Lake in Missouri against a backdrop of dense green forest.