Editor’s Note: Since the publication of this article, Edytka’s has permanently closed.

The Wisconsin Dells aren’t exactly the first place that comes to mind when it comes to anything authentic. The tourist hot spot is meant to provide fun and frolicking and an escape from reality. Among all the bright, shiny plastic, tucked into a strip mall is the most unassuming little spot that you’ll find yourself wanting to head back to again and again. Among all-you-can-eat gorge-fests and chain restaurants, Edytka’s Polish Restaurant is a haven of warm, welcoming comfort. With food like your grandma used to make, this Polish diner in Wisconsin feels welcoming and homey.

Have you ever eaten at this scrumptious Polish diner in Wisconsin? What’s your favorite thing on the menu? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below! And if you know another hidden gem restaurant in Wisconsin, nominate it for a chance to be featured!

If you love trying food from other countries, you have to check out the 24 different restaurants on this list serving up the very best in ethnic food in Wisconsin.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

More to Explore

Polish diner in Wisconsin

What are the best diners in Wisconsin?

Frank's Diner, located in Kenosha, is one of the best diners in Wisconsin. This lunch car is full of classic and comforting eats. Whether you come for breakfast and enjoy a hearty plate of French toast or visit for lunch and scarf down an epic burger, you’ll be blown away by the meals at this humble eatery. Be sure to bring cash! This old school diner doesn’t accept credit cards. For more down-home eats, visit Monty's Blue Plate Diner in Madison. This ‘50s style restaurant serves juicy burgers and scrumptious pies. It’s a delicious taste of nostalgia!

What are the best Polish restaurants in Wisconsin?

If you’re looking for the best pierogies in Wisconsin, you have to pay a visit to Polonez in St. Francis. This authentic Polish restaurant makes some of the best dumplings you’ve ever eaten. Pair your pierogies with a tasty cabbage roll, potato pancake, and sausage link. It’ll be one of the best meals you’ve ever eaten. This is one hidden gem restaurant in Wisconsin you won’t want to pass by.

What are the best hidden gem restaurants in Wisconsin?

Some of the most amazing meals can be found in unlikely settings. The Jail House Restaurant, located in West Bend, is no exception. You may not expect to find mouthwatering steaks and seafood inside an old jail, but Wisconsin is full of delightful surprises. You’ll love the rustic charm and welcoming atmosphere. For more hidden gem eats in Wisconsin, visit Al Corso in Collins. This amazing eatery sits in the middle of a picturesque marsh, and their menu is full of flavorful dishes. Everything is made from the freshest ingredients available, so you know you’re in for an amazing meal.

Explore Wisconsin