10 Remote Small Towns in the U.S. Locals Don’t Want You to Find

There is something special about visiting a small town that typically flies under the radar. These destinations are the hidden gems that you want to keep all to yourself, yet shout about their charm from the rooftops. Many of these small towns are not easily accessible. Rather, they are places that are remote, secluded, and you often have to go out of your way to visit. Below are 10 remote small towns in the U.S. that deserve a spot on every bucket list, have something unique to offer, and locals won't be very happy to see it mentioned on this list. These are some of our favorite small towns that often go unnoticed.

1. Matinicus Island, Maine

Matinicus Island is the definition of a remote destination. In fact, this tiny community is located on the furthest inhabited island off the U.S. East Coast in Penobscot Bay. Not only is this entire area beautiful, quiet, and peaceful, but it’s the ideal place for some time outdoors. Here, you’ll find everything from forests to gorgeous beaches, and it's a place where wildlife is easy to spot and observe. If you are looking for a true off-the-grid adventure, you'll easily find it here.

2. Sussex, New Jersey

Sussex is a small town in New Jersey that checks off all the boxes, especially when it comes to beautiful architecture, history, and delicious food. During your visit, stop by the Early American Tavern, a historic bar and grill dating back to 1843, serving a variety of dishes, including perfectly prepared steaks and delicious comfort food. You also don't want to miss Holland American Bakery, a family-owned establishment serving some of the best and most authentic Dutch pastries. Of course, when you want to spend some time outdoors, you can't miss High Point State Park, the highest point in New Jersey, and a destination with more than 50 miles of trails for summer and winter activities.

3. Keaton Beach, Florida

If you are searching for a getaway with beautiful beaches, loads of history, and a slower pace, Keaton Beach is where you need to go. Located right on the coast, this isn’t your typical Florida destination. This area is known for its undeveloped beaches and shallow, warm waters, perfect for a day of play. If you love to fish, Keaton Beach will not let you down, and it's also a premier scalloping destination in the late summer months. For a peaceful getaway, this small Florida town is truly one of a kind.

4. Taylor, Arkansas

Taylor, Arkansas, is like a best-kept secret, and locals certainly want to keep it that way. This town in Columbia County is home to approximately 600 residents and isn't known for flashy attractions and popular tourist spots. Rather, it's a place where you can slow down and be present. Lake Erling, one of the best fishing lakes in Arkansas, is here and is a popular spot for catching crappie and catfish. You may also want to spend a night under the stars at local campgrounds, hike at nearby Logoly State Park, and chase sunsets, especially the fiery vistas over Lake Erling—these are the slower moments that make this town feel like home.

5. New Buffalo, Michigan

Near many popular tourist destinations, such as Indiana Dunes National Park and Chicago, New Buffalo is often overlooked. But once you know about all the gems hiding here, you’ll quickly place it at the top of your travel wishlist. This town, with approximately 1,700 residents, boasts small-town vibes and has something for everyone. Outdoor enthusiasts will love its location next to Lake Michigan (New Buffalo Beach is a favorite), and its many hiking trails at nearby state parks and preserves. Foodies will crave food and drinks served at iconic restaurants like Redamak’s and at multiple wineries in the area. Even history lovers will be intrigued by the Harbor Country Museum of History + Rail, which is located on the former largest train yard in Southwest Michigan.

6. Washington Island, Wisconsin

Washington Island is the largest island in Wisconsin’s Door County, but it is still quite remote and secluded. When you arrive via ferry, admire the island's incredible beauty and explore its outdoor attractions like Gislason Beach, Sand Dunes Park, and School House Beach. Stop by one of the historic museums or even dive into some delicious food at one of the local restaurants. If you time your visit just right, you can also participate in one of the many festivals, such as the Washington Island Lavender Festival, the Death’s Door BBQ event, or the Washington Island Music Festival.

7. Crane Lake, Minnesota

Located in northern Minnesota, near the Canadian border, is Crane Lake, a small town with approximately 100 residents. It is known as the southern gateway to Voyageurs National Park and is home to a variety of outdoor activities, incredible wildlife, and peaceful adventures. However, that’s just the beginning, as Crane Lake is also near Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness, Vermilion Falls, and Vermilion River Gorge. And while you may find you want to spend most of your time outdoors, when you work up an appetite, this town is full of mom-and-pop shops that will satisfy your every craving.

8. Northwood, Iowa

Northwood, Iowa, is the type of place where you’ll feel right at home the minute you arrive. This community is located just off Interstate 35, but is certainly not a place to drive by. Here, you’ll find the Top of Iowa Welcome Center, one of the most unique rest areas in the U.S., with a gift shop and historic markers, including Patriotic Rock. If you love the outdoors, you'll have plenty to keep you busy as the Shell Rock River runs right through town.

9. Avery, Idaho

Avery is a community that, if you blink, you may miss it as you drive by. Located in northern Idaho, this town is so far out of the way that you likely will not drive by on your own—you must plan to visit. However, despite its remote location and small population, Avery is home to gems like the Avery Museum, incredible hiking trails, and natural features such as the St. Joe River, which make you appreciate Idaho’s beauty.

10. Supai, Arizona

The Village of Supai is unique in many ways. For starters, it is located at the bottom of the Grand Canyon and is not accessible by vehicle. It is approximately eight miles from the nearest road, and access is only possible on foot, by mule, or by helicopter. You must also obtain a permit to enter Supai, and it’s so highly sought after that there’s an annual lottery to receive one. This village is home to the Havasupai Tribe and is known for its extraordinary beauty, especially Havasu Falls and Mooney Falls.  

Many of the towns on our list are not easily accessible and require some effort to visit, but each offers something extraordinary. Whether you visit for an afternoon, a day, or even a week, spend some time searching for the gems that make the town so special—you’ll be grateful you did.

Feeling inspired? Try planning your own trip to one of the best small, remote towns in the U.S. using Only In Your State’s itinerary planner.