5 Waterfront New Jersey Rentals So Stunning They Don’t Feel Real

The scenic shore of New Jersey is perhaps the state’s best-known waterfront area, but the Garden State is also made up of approximately 300 square miles of inland H2O. No matter if you are a lake enthusiast or a lover of the sea, each body of water offers a refreshing escape. If cool breezes, breathtaking sunsets, and extraordinary amenities sound like a vacation to you, check out my list of the best waterfront rentals in New Jersey.

1. Casa Del Pescatore - Little Egg Harbor Township, New Jersey

When you stay at the Casa Del Pescatore in Little Egg Harbor Township, you are sure to experience a relaxing retreat like no other. Spend the day fishing or crabbing the waters just beyond your door, and then cook up your seafood feast in the Airbnb's outdoor kitchen. The newly built rental offering stunning lagoon views also includes beach gear, kayaks, and a floating dock. And the best part is that you don’t even need to battle traffic to get here. If you happen to own a boat, simply motor over and let the vacation begin. This dreamy three-bedroom home sleeps up to six guests, making it ideal for medium-sized groups.

2. The Foxtail - Bridgeton, New Jersey

If you are looking for a waterfront Airbnb in New Jersey far away from the crowds at the shore, The Foxtail in Bridgeton just might be the vacation spot for you and your family. This quaint 1850s farmhouse set along the waters of the Cohansey River offers a tranquil escape for up to eight guests. The brand-new kitchen, fire pit, and outdoor hot tub overlooking the river are some of my favorite guest amenities at this lovely historic home. 

3. Beach Daze - Sea Bright, New Jersey

Beach Daze is a phenomenal rental option for couples, families, and small groups of friends. Located in Sea Bright, just minutes from the Atlantic Highlands Ferry, this beachy two-bedroom bungalow features a hot tub, private deck, nearby beach access, outdoor games, and breathtaking ocean views. The five-star home is pet-friendly and has a fenced-in yard, so feel free to bring your furbabies along to enjoy the fun.

4. Lakefront Cabin - Blairstown, New Jersey

If you prefer to vacation on the lake, you may want to head to Blairstown and stay at this scenic Lakeside Cabin on a sprawling 200-acre farm. Not only can you enjoy swimming, fishing, and boating on the property’s serene five-acre private lake, but you also have use of the home's tennis courts. This three-bedroom lakeside rental comfortably sleeps up to six people. The hosts also accommodate weddings and special gatherings, and guests of these events can rent out additional houses on the property. While you are in town, be sure to stop at the historic Blairstown Diner, an iconic restaurant that was featured in the original 1979 Friday the 13th horror film.

5. Luxe Private Beachfront Retreat - Salem, New Jersey

My final recommendation for one of the best waterfront Airbnbs in New Jersey is the Luxe Private Beachfront Retreat in Salem. This quiet three-bedroom Airbnb on the Delaware River offers beach access, a private deck, and an upscale kitchen. I also simply love that it is so close to fun, family-friendly activities such as the Delaware Children's Museum and the Brandywine Zoo.

Each of these outstanding vacation rentals on the water in New Jersey currently has availability for the coming months, but if you would like to make a reservation, I suggest doing so ASAP. Each unique stay can be booked through the listed Airbnb links. For more scenic getaways beyond the Garden State, be sure to check out these 13 hidden waterfront towns.