4 Trending Rentals in New Jersey That People Book on Repeat (And We See Why)

New Jersey is known for many things, such as having a gorgeous shoreline, being the “Diner Capital of the US,” and having lots of cool diners, historical state parks, and beautiful green spaces, hence the moniker “The Garden State.” With reputable vacation towns like Cape May and “The Jersey Shore”, plus a thriving arts and culture scene, New Jersey has something for everyone. And, when it comes to choosing the best vacation rental in New Jersey to suit your travel needs, there are many wonderful vacation rentals to choose from. All the properties on this list have a 10/10 rating, and we surely see why. 

1. Glamorous Beachfront Stunner - Cape May 

New Jersey’s Cape May has been a favorite destination for families for many generations. Known for its colorful homes, beautiful Victorian architecture, and calm beaches, it is both alluring and satisfying. However, while Cape May boasts many lovely homes, the “Blue Oasis” stands out as a newly renovated beachfront home, featuring four bedrooms, three bathrooms, two spacious decks, and a luxurious open-concept design with upscale coastal décor. With a large outdoor dining area that provides views of the ocean, this sophisticated rental has access to a private beach. If you love watching beautiful sunsets, the convenience of modern amenities, and easy access to Cape May’s dining, shopping, and attractions, then this is the ultimate vacation experience. 

2. Bungalow Home - Point Pleasant Beach

I personally love a vacation stay that gives main character energy, and this modern bungalow is a vacation rental that definitely has lots of character and personality. With fun pops of color and great amenities for families with kids and teens, this property gives families and guests just enough space to feel as if they have freedom, without the loneliness that oversized vacation homes can often bring. This beautiful and playfully decorated home is situated directly on the Boardwalk of Point Pleasant Beach. So, if you have a crew traveling that has differing personality types and traveling styles, there’s a little something for everyone. And, for those who love properties that have that something special when it comes to interior design, you will definitely enjoy the hip, nautical vibes, unique lobster wallpaper in one of the bathrooms (super cute!), surfboards as decor, and the fun, yet intentional, water-themed accent pieces and accessories dispersed throughout the home. 

3. Lakefront Home – West Milford

This unique lakefront property has access to the best views, including a terrace that literally sits beside the waterfront. “On the Rocks” is an exceptional lakefront home that sits high on a rock ledge that overlooks Greenwood Lake. The property boasts panoramic views, luxurious interiors, and modern amenities, ensuring a memorable stay. Parents of small kids, tweens, and teens will be delighted to find that there are many outdoor lounging and seating areas for tanning or just enjoying a great view. And, there’s a game room (with several flatscreens so the kids won’t have to argue about who watches what), and it’s the perfect year-round retreat for relaxation and adventure. 

4. Beautiful Mountain House - Vernon Township

This secluded mountain-view retreat features rooms with floor-to-ceiling windows, a gourmet kitchen, multiple decks with lots of seating, a master suite with a spa tub, a game room, and an outdoor fire pit for the ultimate getaway. If nature-filled walks, apple-picking at a nearby orchard, or heading to a fancy spa are your thing, this serene property is just 11 minutes from the spas at the Crystal Springs Resort, a quick drive away from Warwick, NY (which is known for its lovely apple orchards), and is in very close proximity to hiking trails and other nearby fun attractions. And, for those who travel with avid television watchers, you’ll be pleased to know that the Family Room has a 70” television with streaming services such as Disney, Netflix, Prime Video, HBO Max, and Netflix. If you love a modern, rustic, and minimalistic vibe, and have tweens, teens, or cousins who like to travel in groups (there’s a game room with a foosball table, classic Nintendo, and an air hockey table), this vacation rental is the perfect stay for you.

Choosing the right vacation rental doesn’t have to be daunting. In fact, there are so many wonderful properties waiting to be discovered! From a glamorous beachfront stunner with sweeping views of the ocean to a modern and minimalist lakefront home, there is a stay waiting to help create your next memorable staycation, family vacation, or romantic getaway. Want to keep the adventure going? Map out your next getaway using Only In Your State’s itinerary planner.