Urban legends in New Mexico are plentiful, which is partly because, compared to other states, New Mexico is long on history, low on people, and it covers a large area. This means that solitude is easy to come by. While that’s a reason why many people love the Land of Enchantment, the New Mexico urban legends or cryptids in New Mexico that you dismissed by daylight become a lot more sinister when you’re driving down a deserted road at night. Here are 10 New Mexico urban legends to keep you looking over your shoulder!

1. La Llorona
Rio Grande, Albuquerque, NM, USA
Wikimedia Commons/Karla Andrew
Most people in New Mexico have heard of La Llorona. She is usually described as a tall, slender lady, with dark hair, who is dressed in white. People have spotted the spectre of this mysterious, weeping woman by rivers and streams throughout New Mexico. There are many variations on her story. When you boil it down, the tales all center on a woman who, after being wronged by a man, drowns her own children. She is believed to lure children to water and then drown them. La Llorona is usually sighted near the Rio Grande.
2. Bigfoot
Valles Caldera, New Mexico 87025, USA
Flickr/Steve Rotman
Bigfoot has been sighted in many parts of the country including New Mexico. In 2011, the Bigfoot Field Researchers Organization (yes, that’s a thing) shot footage showing a figure that was over 7 feet tall in the Valles Caldera.
3. Aliens under Dulce
Dulce, NM 87528, USA
Flickr/Nancy and Randy
Of all urban legends in New Mexico this is one of the most oft-repeated. According to legend, a secret military base lies under Dulce. This small town is on the Jicarilla Apache Reservation, next to the Colorado border. The base, believed to be located under Archuleta Mesa, is supposedly a joint human and extra terrestrial operation. Believers claim that, when relations broke down, there was a gun battle between the humans and aliens.
4. Teratorns
Las Cruces, NM, USA
Flickr/Heather Paul
Nowadays, you don’t hear much about teratorns. These birds, which were the ancestors of vultures, lived on this planet millions of years ago and have long been extinct. Or have they? Eyewitnesses claim to have seen massive birds, which resemble teratorns, within the last decade in the Las Cruces area. (There have been similar reports in parts of Texas.) To make matters more unnerving, such sightings aren’t new. Sightings of teratorn-like creatures, sometimes called thunderbirds, were reported in Lordsburg during the 1800s.
5. La Mala Hora
Flickr/Peter Roome
If you’re traveling alone through New Mexico after midnight, beware! If urban legends are to be believed you may encounter a shape-shifting demon in the road. Sometimes it looks like an amorphous black lump. But, if this creature appears at a crossroads in the form of a woman, it is perceived as an omen of death.

Related Stories

You'll Never Look At Donuts The Same Way After Trying Amy's Donuts In New Mexico

You'll Never Look At Donuts The Same Way After Trying Amy's Donuts In New Mexico

 This Cozy House Is The Best Home Base For Your Adventures In Albuquerque, New Mexico

This Cozy House Is The Best Home Base For Your Adventures In Albuquerque, New Mexico

 This Speakeasy Hidden Down An Alley In New Mexico Is Perfect For A Date Night

This Speakeasy Hidden Down An Alley In New Mexico Is Perfect For A Date Night
6. Urraca Mesa
Urraca Mesa, New Mexico 87714, USA
Flickr/Elliot Cable
You expect the Boy Scouts at Philmont Scout Ranch to tell scary campfire stories. But Urraca Mesa, which is located on the ranch, has been a spooky place long before any Boy Scouts showed up. Native American tribes thought this place was the entrance to the demon world! From an aerial perspective, the mesa does seem to resemble a human skull. Taking all that into account, it's not surprising Urraca Mesa is billed as one of the creepiest places in New Mexico.
7. New Mexico State Penitentiary
State Penitentiary Administration Office, New Mexico 87508, USA
Wikimedia Commons/Shelka04
The state pen in New Mexico is renowned for being one of the most haunted places in New Mexico, and that's due to the number of people murdered there during the 1980 prison riot. It was one of the worst prison riots to ever occur in the United States and at least 33 inmates died.
8. The Death Waltz
Fort Union Drive, Fort Union Dr, Santa Fe, NM 87505, USA
Flickr/Images By Lane
This urban legend is about a soldier based at Fort Union in New Mexico. According to the story, he fell for a flighty, gold-digging woman. She agreed to marry him and, when the soldier was sent out to fight the Apaches, she swore that if he died in battle, she would never marry another. You can guess what happened next.

At the woman's wedding ball, the soldier’s ghost crashed the party. The guests and band fell into a trance while the ghost danced with the woman, sucking the life out of her in the process.
9. Skinwalkers
Flickr/OpenThreads
Skinwalkers are part of Navajo folklore. These are human witches who are able to change into animals at night. Skinwalkers are considered evil because their power is attained by murdering a close relative. These witches are believed to adopt the shape of owls, coyotes, foxes, crows, or wolves.
10. Chupacabra
Flickr/Michael Gras, M.Ed.
A chupacabra is a type of monster that allegedly sustains itself by draining the blood of livestock. Livestock attacks are sometimes attributed to this creature, also called a goat-sucker.

What New Mexico urban legends did you grow up hearing about?

Some claims about New Mexico are odd rather than scary. That’s certainly the case with the Taos Hum, an inexplicable phenomenon in New Mexico. In addition to mythical creatures in New Mexico, there are also plenty of haunted places in New Mexico. If you’d like to explore them, consider taking a scary road trip in New Mexico.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

New Mexico Urban Legends

Daniella DiRienzo | July 01, 2022

What are the scariest haunted attractions in New Mexico?

There seems to be no shortage of haunted places in New Mexico, and the KiMo Theater is one of them. One of the state’s most infamous haunts, the theater is purportedly haunted by the ghost of a six-year-old boy named Bobby, who, along with several others, was killed in the theater in 1951 when a water heater exploded. Today, his ghost, which is classified as a poltergeist, likes to cause mischief and has been known to interfere with electricity, open and close doors, and drop cables and other equipment from the ceiling.

What are the creepiest cemeteries in New Mexico?

Several cemeteries in New Mexico are reportedly haunted and that includes Dawson Cemetery. Billed as one of the most haunted places in New Mexico, cemetery visitors have reported numerous strange happenings over the years, including seeing spectral lights and hazy apparitions floating among the graves. The cemetery’s spooky reputation isn’t too surprising once you learn of the area’s past. Back in the early 1900s, one of the worst mining disasters in history occurred just a few miles from the cemetery. A decade later, there was another terrible mining accident. Present-day visitors to the cemetery suspect that the phantom lights are the headlamps of the deceased miners’ helmets.

Are there any ghost towns in New Mexico?

The creepy places in the Land of Enchantment aren’t limited to local haunts. Spooky spots come in all forms, including ghost towns. Though the exact number is unknown, it’s estimated that there are more than 400 ghost towns in New Mexico. Most of the state’s ghost towns are comprised solely of foundations, while others feature old mining equipment and other remnants of the past.

Related Articles