A unicorn is a magical beast only found in legend, but it can also mean a one-of-a-kind surprise that can’t be found anywhere else. Chubby Unicorn, a new donut shop in Bayville, NJ, fits both those bills! Yes, there’s a mythical beast on the logo – although we don’t know, something looks a little odd about the friendly mascot! It’s also a standout for its fresh-made donuts, its creative lattes, and its deliciously creamy frozen yogurt served during the summer. Once you’ve tried the goods at this hole-in-the-wall that opened in early 2023, you’ll see why locals are coming back time and time again. Located less than two miles away from the Toms River waterfront, you’ll want to make a visit here a part of your summer on the shore.

Hm, something's a little different about the unicorn on the logo of Chubby Unicorn Donut Shop, but we think he's perfect just the way he is.
The Chubby Unicorn Donut Shop/Facebook
That pretty much sums up the atmosphere at this new Bayville donut shop - it's a little scrappy, a little offbeat, but it comes together into a small but lovable package.
Chubby Unicorn Donut Shop/Google Local
The donuts here are made fresh everyday, and you'll be blown away by the delicious varieties.
The Chubby Unicorn Donut Shop/Facebook

Related Stories

Meet The Famous Baker Who Inspired An Iconic Dessert Chain In New Jersey

Meet The Famous Baker Who Inspired An Iconic Dessert Chain In New Jersey

 Ice Cream Nachos Are Sweeping The Nation And You Can Find Them At This New Jersey Parlor

Ice Cream Nachos Are Sweeping The Nation And You Can Find Them At This New Jersey Parlor

 This Eclectic Restaurant In New Jersey Has Its Very Own Bakery

This Eclectic Restaurant In New Jersey Has Its Very Own Bakery
The quirky atmosphere of the shop can also be found in the donut designs, some of which are almost too cute to eat. Almost!
The Chubby Unicorn Donut Shop/Facebook
You can usually expect to find some seasonal specialties on display, which is the perfect reason to come back time and time again.
The Chubby Unicorn Donut Shop/Facebook
The donut shop is also a coffee shop, selling lattes and other caffeinated specialties - something that will be very welcome in the summer!
Chubby Unicorn Donut Shop/Google Local
So will the frozen yogurt, which will be starting up as the weather heats up. It's the perfect creamy, delicious finish to a visit here.
Chubby Unicorn Donut Shop/Google Local

Have you visited Chubby Unicorn Donut Shop? Let us know what you thought of this new donut shop in Bayville, NJ in the comments section. You can visit the official website and Facebook page to keep up on the daily specials. While you’re down the shore, why not head to Barnegat Light and sample some of the Jersey Shore’s best pancakes?

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore New Jersey

Featured Addresses
Chubby Unicorn Donut Shop, 271 Atlantic City Blvd, Bayville, NJ 08721, USA