The bay beaches of Cape May, New Jersey are home to countless treasures. Not only can you find sea glass, shells, sharks’ teeth, and beautiful quartz stones known as Cape May Diamonds, but the area is also known to have arrowheads. You can find them in the sand near Sunset and Higbee Beaches on the Higbee Beach Loop Trail. It is important to preserve these historic artifacts, so remember to admire but not remove them. If you decide to visit Higbee Beach, why not make an adventure out of it and journey along the Higbee Beach Loop Trail? It’s often called one of the best trails in New Jersey.

Related Stories

The New Jersey Trail With A Beach, Fishing Pier, And Historic Sites You Just Can't Beat

The New Jersey Trail With A Beach, Fishing Pier, And Historic Sites You Just Can't Beat

18 Best Hiking Trails In New Jersey: The Top-Rated Hiking Trails to Visit in 2024

18 Best Hiking Trails In New Jersey: The Top-Rated Hiking Trails to Visit in 2024

The Rugged And Remote Hiking Trail In New Jersey That Is Well-Worth The Effort

The Rugged And Remote Hiking Trail In New Jersey That Is Well-Worth The Effort

If you want to see some of the amazing finds along the Higbee Beach Loop Trail, check out this video from Shell Casing Kid on YouTube!

Many of the arrowheads in this area are black, dark brown, or charcoal grey. They are often along the waterline but can be anywhere. Most are believed to have originated with the Lenni-Lenape Tribe and date back hundreds and even thousands of years. They’re part of New Jersey history and should be left where they are found so that others can enjoy them for years to come. If you want to guarantee a local arrowhead sighting, you can visit the Cape May County Museum. They have a wonderful collection!

You can learn more about New Jersey’s Higbee Beach Loop Trail on AllTrails. If you think you’re likely to take on some of the best New Jersey hiking trails, you might want to subscribe to AllTrails Plus.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Best Beaches In New Jersey

Where Can I Find The Best Beaches In New Jersey? 

In addition to the many popular Boardwalk towns and tourist destinations, New Jersey has some amazing under-the-radar beach destinations along the shore. Here are some places you might be able to enjoy the shore without the crowds!

  • Poverty Beach is that rarest of unicorns - an under-the-radar beach in New Jersey! It's named this way because it used to be the chosen vacation area for lower-income workers who couldn't afford the high prices at the popular Cape May beach resorts. Today, it's known for its pristine sands and blue waters, and its beautiful views of the surrounding beach houses and landscape.
  • If you're looking for a classic New Jersey beach town with a much more quaint atmosphere, you'll want to head to Allenhurst. This tiny, historic town only has about 500 year-round residents and is within walking distance of Asbury Park. It's known for its historic residential district, its popular beach club, a thriving restaurant scene, and a beautiful beach that lacks the hustle and bustle of nearby towns.
  • Manasquan is another laid-back beach town, with its peaceful waterfront being popular with those who want to beat the crowds. Without a large boardwalk or major tourist attractions, it's a perfect place to just enjoy the waves. But during the warmer months, you might be in for a surprise treat - waves of bioluminescent plankton that can turn the waves stunning shares of blue and give visitors quite the show!
  • Located just past Point Pleasant Beach as the last spot on the North Jersey Coast Line train, Bay Head is another of those quiet beaches that often slips under the radar. It's a tiny town that's mostly a residential area - but its beach might be the best place in New Jersey to find sea glass! These multi-colored pieces of "mermaid loot" are often used for making jewelry, but they also make beautiful collectibles for kids.

 

Explore New Jersey