Swim at This Iconic Waterfall Swimming Hole in New Jersey for the Ultimate Outdoor Fun

Nothing says summer like cooling off in the inviting pool at a New Jersey waterfall swimming hole. Luckily, the Garden State has so many quality places to go swimming, yet it's hard to beat Buttermilk Falls, a swimming hole in Mendham Township, tucked away in the forest and far away from your everyday routine. A day trip to this popular swimming spot checks all the boxes of everything we love about summertime in New Jersey: time in the woods, the draw of a waterfall, and the promise of a splashing good time.

Not to mention the scenic hike through the lush woodlands with water views and the sounds of India Brook flowing, which only adds to this summertime adventure. Find out why this swimming hole in New Jersey is worth the visit.

Why This New Jersey Waterfall Swimming Hole Is so Special

New Jersey is home to a handful of waterfalls called Buttermilk Falls, but the one we're featuring today is located within the India Brook Park and Buttermilk Nature Falls Area in Mendham, about 25 miles from Newark. A visit to Morris County's Buttermilk Falls, a lesser-known New Jersey waterfall, combines two of our favorite summer pastimes: hiking and swimming.

Tiny in comparison to the towering 85-foot cascade, the tallest waterfall in New Jersey, at Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area, this waterfall is secluded, tucked inside the forests, and the refreshing pool makes the swimming hole an ideal spot for locals to cool off in the summer.

The area is less developed than major parks in New Jersey, but it boasts a rich landscape with flowing streams, ponds, and wooded ravines. In my opinion, this only adds to its appeal - it will feel like you've discovered an untouched part of New Jersey's landscape that not many get to experience.

What To Know Before You Go

The circuit trail, called Buttermilk Falls and Frog Pond Loop, is a little over two miles and is rated as easy, meaning it's appropriate for most skill levels. The parking area for this trail near Combs Hollow Road is limited—there's only space for about seven cars, so your best bet is to arrive early. Once you've parked and set out on the trail, you'll enjoy a well-maintained path with a few stream crossings here and there. You'll get some variety in terrain, too; portions of the trail take you on a steep incline. Your efforts will be well-rewarded when you see your waterfall oasis, not far from the parking lot.

You'll notice that the trail is well-marked and easy to follow, although it can sometimes get a little muddy. If it's rained recently, be sure to bring shoes or boots that you don't mind getting dirty. The trail is dog-friendly, so be sure to bring your four-legged hiking companion with you.

The waterfall has a real allure to it, and hikers agree that the sound of the rushing water is just as lovely as the sight. Despite being smaller, the waterfall seems to have an impressive volume, and it's fun to simply sit and absorb these lovely surroundings. You don't necessarily have to take a dip in the pool to enjoy the waterfall, but on a hot summer day, there are few things more refreshing than a swim.

The waterfall is close to the entrance, so if you're hiking with little ones, it may be easier to turn around and return to the beginning of the trail rather than complete the loop. If you and your crew are looking for a top-notch local lunch spot after your hiking and swimming adventure, head to the nearby Longfellow's Sandwich Deli for an outstanding made-to-order sub.

Have you experienced this lovely waterfall hiking trail in New Jersey before? Feel free to share this article with a fellow hiking enthusiast and start planning your summer adventure! Looking for even more hiking inspiration? We've put together a road trip of our favorite waterfalls in New Jersey, and there's something for every kind of hiker!

Before you plan your visit, check out the India Brook Natural Area website, and I like using the official Visit New Jersey tourism site to learn more about the attractions when I visit new places.