The Ultimate Pie Shop Road Trip In Indiana Is As Charming As It Is Sweet
By Tori Jane|Published May 24, 2022
×
Tori Jane
Author
Tori Jane is a storm chaser, writer, photographer, and the village idiot - in that order. When she's not out and about dancing with the meanest storms on planet Earth for funsies she can be found wandering, shooting landscapes, writing, editing photos, and otherwise up to no good. Legend has it that she can also be occasionally spotted typing up short bios in the third person, but those rumors are unsubstantiated.
You know what’s pretty sweet? Pie. Literally. What’s sweeter than that? How about a pie road trip in Indiana that you can do in just one day, given that you stop at each location and stay a little while for a slice and good conversation. To embark upon this delightful, delicious journey, and to add or remove stops as you please, check out the official Google Maps route we created for you. Get in the car hungry, and end the trip stuffed with the best pie in Indiana! Let’s go:
Let's be real here: it's going to be difficult to top this first stop. Marilyn's bakery is one of those places that, from the moment you walk in, you're greeted with the nearly overwhelming scent of incredible baked goods - including what might just be the best pie in Indiana. Plan to take something home with you from this one!
Advertisement
Next, we skidaddle on over to Schererville for one of Indiana's most beloved eateries and bakeries, Baker's Square.
With so many unique and awe-inspiring, party-in-your-mouth flavors, it might be kind of hard to decide what you want to get at Baker's Square. After all, it isn't just pies served up here - there's so many choices that might just stray from the "pie" part of this trip just... this... once. There's a reason it's one of the most popular bakeries in Indiana!
If there's anything we really, really love, it's local mom-and-pop stops where you can get all sorts of things there and only there, making you crave a quick return to the tastebud nirvana you've discovered. Enter Lisa's Pie Shop, a wonderful little bakery that has some of the best baked goods in Indiana, including those to-die-for pies.
Our second-to-last stop is at My Sugar Pie, an award-winning delight nestled in Zionsville serving up some of the greatest pies known to man all year 'round.
No matter what the occasion is, it doesn't get better than a gift of pie. Now, whether or not you're the recipient of this gift you totally could have got for yourself is up to you, but you know what we say... treat yo'self. My Sugar Pie might serve up the best pumpkin pie in Indiana.
Finally, we end up at Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery, another wonderful local shop filled top-to-bottom with the best-ever baked goods that'll leave you craving more for days after you've left.
Lovers of that home-made sensational deliciousness will adore every shop on this list, but they might just adore the pies at this little slice of tastebud heaven most. We can't get enough of the unique flavors, and you can just taste the love that goes into the crafting of each and every baked goody in the shop. This is easily one of our favorite, top-rated bakeries in Indiana.
So there you have it: what might be one of the tastiest road trips you’ll ever embark upon! If you liked this trip, be sure to check out the just-as-tasty donut road trip in Indiana for even more bakeries galore.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
