Food lovers of the Midwest, have we got a restaurant for you! Tucked away in the beautiful Amish countryside of Shipshewana, Indiana, is the Blue Gate Restaurant, an enormous complex of shopping, dining, theatre, and more. It’s so much more than just a restaurant, but the restaurant aspect of things is easily one of the best parts. Better still: Blue Gate might just have the biggest dessert selection in Indiana, with pies, cookies, strudels, and tons more. If you’re the owner of a sweet tooth, you’re going to want to come out to Shipshewana and experience this incredible powerhouse of deliciousness. Check it out – and be sure to unbutton the top button on your pants, considering you’ll need the extra room.

Once you've been to Blue Gate Restaurant, we're pretty sure you may never want to leave.
Blue Gate Restaurant & Theatre/Facebook
Between the seemingly endless things to do here - shopping, entertainment, food - it might be hard to know where to begin.
Well, we're here for a specific reason today: Blue Gate Restaurant just so happens to have one of the best dessert selections in Indiana.
NC_ManofLetters/TripAdvisor
Yes, the lunch and dinner menu is to die for, but we personally may or may not be hopelessly obsessed with sweets.
No matter what you love to eat for dessert, as long as it's baked, you'll likely find it here.
Blue Gate Restaurant & Theatre/Facebook
We probably can't even list all the options, but here are a few:

Related Stories

There's A Dessert Haven Hiding In Indiana And It's Everything You've Dreamed And More

There's A Dessert Haven Hiding In Indiana And It's Everything You've Dreamed And More

 This Sugary-Sweet Ice Cream Shop In Indiana Serves Enormous Portions You’ll Love

This Sugary-Sweet Ice Cream Shop In Indiana Serves Enormous Portions You’ll Love

 This Small-Town Candy Store In Indiana Sells The Most Amazing Homemade Fudge You'll Ever Try

This Small-Town Candy Store In Indiana Sells The Most Amazing Homemade Fudge You'll Ever Try
Pies. Jellies. Cookies.
Blue Gate Restaurant & Theatre/Facebook
Sweet breads. Cinnamon buns that are bigger than your head. Cakes. Cake rolls. Donuts. Cashew crunch. Chocolates. Candies... seriously, the list continues.
We honestly think you could just skip the dinner (as hard as that is considering how delicious everything served here is) and go straight for dessert.
Blue Gate Restaurant & Theatre/Facebook
Even if you're not huge on having a sweet tooth, we think you'll find something to fall in love with at Blue Gate. Take your time eating, but not too long...
...there just might be a show to catch here later!
Blue Gate Restaurant & Theatre/Facebook

If you’d like more information about Blue Gate, its outrageous dessert menu, and all the goings-on you can expect while you’re here – including entertainment and show schedules – be sure to visit the official Blue Gate Restaurant website. You can also visit its Facebook page for more consistent updates.

Need more delicious Hoosier State staples? How about one with a view? Check out these awesome lakeside restaurants in Indiana you need to add to your bucket list!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana

Featured Addresses
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery, 195 N Van Buren St, Shipshewana, IN 46565, USA