Hey, so, quick question: what do you look for when choosing a place to go for, say, a day trip? Is it something about the surrounding natural beauty there, or is it the things to do in whatever town you end up in? Do you lean toward places where you already know people, or maybe places where you hope to make new friends? Okay, all of those are good starts, but what about pie? Yeah, pie. Hear us out: why not go somewhere that has a killer pie shop and simply expand your day trip from there? We think it’s genius. Well, it just so happens that Zionsville is the perfect place for this, and it’s home to a shop that might just have the best pie in Indiana. Once you’re done with the pie, explore the rest of the town, too.

For the full menu, as well as the most up-to-date hours and specials, be sure to check out the official My Sugar Pie website. Where do you find the best pie in Indiana? Tell us about your favorite spots in the comments!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Explore Indiana