A Wyoming Dining Experience so Exceptional, It’s Nationally Recognized

New York and Connecticut might be at the top of the pizza hierarchy, but I am awfully proud that a Wyoming restaurant has made its own bold statement. In a state known for cowboy boots and rodeo roots, Alibi Wood Fire Pizzaria & Bakery in Laramie is rewriting the script. Baking one blistered crust at a time, this beloved bakery joint has its patrons coming back for more. 

Even celebrity chefs can’t get enough of the delectable creations here. From freshly baked bread and pastries to stacked deli sandwiches to woodfire pizza, this beloved restaurant in Wyoming has something for everyone. With the Laramie Mountains as its backyard and a wood-fired oven at its heart, this popular pizza spot is where bold flavors meet mountain vibes to create a nationally recognized dining experience in Wyoming. Let’s discover this exceptional restaurant that elevates gourmet pizza to the next level.

Discover Alibi Wood Fire Pizzaria & Bakery

Alibi started as a labor of love, bringing artisanal wood-fired pizzas to the heart of Wyoming. Its owners, Kerri and Ethan Smith, passionate about crafting bold flavors and homemade eats, set out to redefine what pizza could be in a region better known for hearty, plate-sized steaks and rustic fry bread. Today, Alibi has earned a reputation not only for its exceptional food but also for its welcoming ambiance — a rare gem these days.

What's even more special is that Alibi isn't just any ol' pizza joint. A visit here is a three-for-one dream for foodies looking to dig into everything that Laramie's dining scene has to offer: a bakery in the wee hours of the morning, a hand-made sourdough and artisan bread specialist in the afternoons, and an acclaimed wood-fired pizza hangout in the evenings. You can't go wrong!

What to Expect When You Visit Alibi

The moment you step inside, the aroma of smoldering oak wood and bubbling cheese envelops you. The centerpiece of the restaurant is its bright red, custom-built wood-fired oven, which churns out epic pies with perfectly crispy crusts and just a hint of char.

A quick peek at the menu and it's clear that Alibi’s pizza options are anything but ordinary. Take the Pork Love, a carnivorous masterpiece topped with Alibi's signature rustic crushed tomato sauce, spicy pepperoni, two types of salami, capocollo, and prosciutto.

The Rocket comes beautifully topped with garlic olive oil, goat cheese, fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, dressed arugula, and a bevy of other add-ons. Or, for those seeking even heartier fare, the Cowboy Beef Brisket is the pie that has landed Alibi on, not one, but two episodes of Diners, Drive-ins, and Dives. It seriously delivers with smoky brisket, béchamel sauce, hickory-smoked brisket, and multiple cheeses, plus a sweet and tangy drizzling of horseradish cream and honey.

Even the classics, like the Margherita, shine with locally sourced ingredients and inventive twists — a fantastic blend of old-world Italian techniques and hearty Wyoming flavors. Be sure to pair your meal with one of their house cocktails or a locally brewed beer for the full Alibi experience!

Alibi Is More Than Just Pizza

Pizza may be the headliner, but Alibi’s menu doesn’t stop there. This pizzeria also offers an impressive lineup of piled-high sandwiches, entrees, artisan breads, and even indulgent bakery items.

Nearly two dozen fresh-baked, rustic loaf options are available every day. Think domed sweet breads, like Apricot Pecan and Cranberry Walnut, and hearty sandwich loaves like Sesame Wheat, Ciabatta, and Rye — all pillowy soft with the perfect amount of bite, made using traditional sourdough techniques and natural leavening.

The breakfast pastries are all handmade as well — fluffy, sweet, and simply divine — making them the perfect start to a workday. Bear claws, buns, berry tarts, brioches … you name it! (Plus a healthy dose of macarons, mini cakes, muffins, and more in between.) Keep an eye on Alibi's social media for the daily lineup!

Bonus: if you can't make it to Laramie, you'll find an assortment of goodies available at Paramount Café in Cheyenne as well.

Why Visit Alibi Wood Fire Pizzaria & Bakery?

In my opinion, what sets Alibi Wood Fire Pizza apart isn’t just the food — it’s the atmosphere. I especially adore the seating options here, featuring an inviting indoor space with an open view of the kitchen and a welcoming outdoor patio shaded by trees. On summer evenings, the patio comes alive with live music and twinkling string lights, creating a vibe that's both intimate and vibrant. In the colder months, the warm glow of the wood-fired oven turns the indoor dining area into a cozy retreat. We love the friendly, backyard-esque vibe!

Its Food Network appearances may have launched it into the spotlight, but Alibi Wood Fire Pizzaria & Bakery's attention to detail and use of time-honored techniques have made it well deserving of a visit. Whether you’re devouring a hot slice that feels straight out of your Nonna's kitchen or enjoying a sweet pastry in the mountain air on the patio, one thing’s for certain: this isn’t just grabbing a cheesy slice to go, it’s a Laramie experience worth savoring!

Have you ever been to this popular restaurant in Laramie? If so, do you agree that it's an exceptional Wyoming dining experience? What is your favorite restaurant in the Cowboy State? Tell us on our nomination page - we'd love to hear from you.

Want more top foodie spots in Wyoming? Use Only In Your State’s itinerary planner to discover more hidden gem restaurants that folks can't get enough of.