Most of the time, hitting up the local brewery for happy hour means a mealtime tradeoff: great brews in exchange for subpar food. A basket of soggy wings or communal peanut basket... brewpubs aren't typically known for their cuisine. Typically. Nostalgia Brewing isn't your typical Ohio brewpub. This microbrewery in Gahanna, Ohio, has made a name for itself as something of a double threat: not only are the craft brews robust and refreshing, but the food is delicious and surprisingly nuanced. In fact, this small-town brewpub makes what many call the best grilled cheese in Ohio.
I know what you're thinking: who am I to say what's the best grilled cheese in Ohio? What grilled cheese deity granted me that power?
Our readers... y'all! Here at OnlyInYourState we encourage readers to nominate their favorite restaurants, attractions, accommodations, and places in their home states. These nominations make their way to each state writer's inbox... and let me just say, my inbox has been flooded with folks singing the praises of one restaurant in Gahanna, Ohio: Nostalgia Brewing!
This brewpub has become a beloved hub in the small town of Gahanna, Ohio, since its arrival in 2019. Under current owner Timm Miller's leadership, Nostalgia has continued to focus on brewing great craft beer and creating a business with a distinctly Ohio ethos.
And while Nostalgia certainly stands out for its refreshing IPAs, pilsners, and ales, the brewpub has another trick up its sleeve...
...delicious grilled cheese sandwiches. As mentioned before, our readers have rallied behind Nostalgia Brewing, citing the restaurant's grilled cheese as a standout.
Nostalgia Brewing's grilled cheese sandwiches have taken on cult status in town, with a lineup of three grilled cheeses on the menu: Buffalo Chicken, Pulled Pork, and a good, old-fashioned classic: the aptly-named "Nostalgic."
What sets these sandwiches apart? Our readers cite their perfect proportions of bread-to-filling-to-cheese: bread "that's buttery-yet-crispy" and cheese that gives the classic "pull" turophiles love.
And really, what goes better with beer... than cheese? Nostalgia has it down.
In short, Nostalgia Brewing is a must visit and sure to have you singing the praises of what's easily the best grilled cheese in Ohio. And paired with a cold IPA? Perfection. Learn more at the Nostalgia Brewing website and be sure to give this small-town brewery in Ohio a follow on Facebook.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest updates and news
Thank you for subscribing!