The Thanksgiving Sandwich at This Michigan Restaurant Beats the Real Meal

Finding a traditional Thanksgiving sandwich in Michigan was no easy feat, y’all. Sure, the Mitten State is home to some of the best sandwich stops in the country, but a leftover turkey Thanksgiving sandwich? Nowhere to be found. You know the one I mean, right? Soft bread that sticks to your thumbs, turkey stacked like someone panicked and just kept slicing, stuffing that never quite stays inside the sandwich, and that swipe of cranberry sauce that looks like a crime scene but tastes like glory. I searched high and low for something that honored that chaotic, beloved tradition and couldn’t find anything that fit the classic model.

Now, I did find a Thanksgiving waffle nearby: stuffing pressed into a waffle iron and served with gravy syrup. A brilliant idea, truly. Their hours didn’t align with my lifestyle, though, which is to say I was hungry and impatient. I’ll get there eventually, and you know I’ll tell you every detail like I’m recapping a family reunion. For now, though, I went to Mudgie’s Deli and Wine Bar for their Turkey Trot, which turned out to be a very, very good move.

I had never been to Mudgie’s before, even though everyone in Detroit seems to talk about it with the affection usually reserved for childhood pets. Located in Corktown, it sits right by the coolest glove factory building I have ever seen. I fell in love instantly; if a building could give a thumbs up, this one did. The vibe inside Mudgie’s is… well, cool. No need to frame it any other way. Handcrafted signs, a bar that begs you to stay longer than planned, a dining room humming with regulars, and a little wine and takeout shop that feels like a secret hidden in plain sight.

Our server set the tone immediately. She thought everything was “so cute,” which made me think the experience was so cute. She poured me an incredible glass of orange wine—bright, tart, a little funky—and crafted a bourbon cocktail for my partner that he sipped like it was a sacred ritual. Cocktails at lunch? Absolutely. This is research.

Corktown itself deserves a moment because it’s one of those Detroit neighborhoods that feels alive in a very local way. Independent shops, street art peeking out around corners, historic buildings that look like they have stories they’d spill if given a glass of wine. Across from Mudgie’s sits a playground Greg Mudge helped bring to life. And soon, a local street will carry his name. The man built a deli that became a Detroit institution, making generosity look effortless. People still leave candles and notes outside for him, a testament to the fact that food can build community and a person can build far more than a business.

Mudgie’s is known for sourcing Michigan-made products, championing local farmers, and serving sandwiches with real personality. They’ve racked up awards for years (Best Deli, Best Sandwich, Best Soup) you name it. Loyal fans have opinions as strong as Detroit coffee, and I now understand why.

The Turkey Trot was the reason for my visit: roasted turkey, sharp cheddar, dried cranberries, fresh apple, walnuts, mustard with actual attitude, and mixed greens folded into warm flatbread. That mustard? Among the best I’ve ever tasted, and I would not exaggerate about mustard. Each bite felt like a gourmet version of the chaotic Thanksgiving sandwich we all secretly adore, but with balance, intention, and crunch. A refined Detroit creation that transforms the Thanksgiving sandwich into gourmet comfort. It’s a holiday upgrade you’ll crave year-round. My partner ordered the Sho’Nuff so I could compare turkey two ways: mine cold and his warm. He skipped the cream cheese because dairy and he do not get along, but even imagining that strawberry cream cheese in the mix felt magnificent. We made up for no sweets on the sandwich by having a slice of Dutch apple pie.

Now, I will admit: I eyed the menu like I was planning a heist. The Cuban called to me like an old Florida friend—ham, pork, Swiss, pickles—everything I’ve been missing. The Brooklyn with beer cheese and brisket nearly distracted me from my mission. Even the McNabb vegan wrap sounded like something I’d enjoy on a day when I’m behaving myself. Mudgie’s doesn’t do boring food. They do food that makes you think about your order long after you’ve eaten it.

After finishing the Turkey Trot and my orange wine, our bartender asked if we wanted anything to go. I’ve been on a quest to find a Chablis like the one I had in New York: crisp, cold, clean, like drinking an iceberg. I described it in borderline dramatic detail, and their wine expert came over, listened patiently, and walked me to the wine shop with the enthusiasm of someone matchmaking. I left with two bottles (neither a Chablis!), a full belly, and a newfound sense of hope. Honestly, what more could you ask for?

Detroit showed up for me on this one. The hunt for a Thanksgiving sandwich led me to a neighborhood gem, a community legacy, and a deli that makes you feel like you’re exactly where you should be. So plan a trip to Michigan. Visit Detroit. Wander Corktown, maybe swing by the old train station or visit the nearby Motown Museum, and absolutely eat at Mudgie’s. After all that searching, I found the Thanksgiving sandwich I’d been craving, and I think you should try it too.

Find the next vacation of your dreams using Only In Your State's Trip Planner!