When most people think of Rocky Mountain hikes, they think of lots of verdant trees and spectacular 360-degree views galore. But hikes at Carter Lake in Colorado are different, as there is also a darker side to the great outdoors here that fewer people realize. Take, for instance, this haunted hike in Colorado that will definitely make you want to run for the hills!

Located just south of Loveland is Carter Lake.
TripAdvisor/richbonilla
Carter Lake is a popular three-mile-long, one-mile-wide lake that hides a dark and morbid secret.
Known for its trails, fishing, boating, and rock climbing, Carter Lake is crowded throughout most of the year.
Ginger Virginia Ikeda/Google Maps
This is by not only outdoor enthusiasts, but by alleged spirits as well.
As the story goes, a man by the name of Bennet lived in the area some 100 years ago.
TripAdvisor/nsurdulescu
And he unfortunately met his fate in the most tragic of ways.

Related Stories

The Legends Of The Gold Camp Road In Colorado May Send Chills Down Your Spine

The Legends Of The Gold Camp Road In Colorado May Send Chills Down Your Spine

 The Story Behind This Ghost Town Cemetery In Colorado Will Chill You To The Bone

The Story Behind This Ghost Town Cemetery In Colorado Will Chill You To The Bone

 The Legend Of The Third Bridge In Colorado Will Make Your Hair Stand On End

The Legend Of The Third Bridge In Colorado Will Make Your Hair Stand On End
Due to a land dispute, Bennet is said to have been shot and killed along one of the roads.
Flickr/Gideon Tsang
But, despite meeting his demise in the most horrible of ways, he supposedly never really left his Colorado home.
According to numerous Carter Lake visitors, Bennet can still be seen around the premises.
Flickr/Paolo Signorini
So keep your eyes peeled for the shadow of a man in old fashioned clothes who seemingly disappears whenever approached.
It may hard to believe this beautiful lake holds such a sinister story.
Justin Way/Google Maps
Nevertheless, the Carter Lake hauntings stories persist. It's just another part of the haunted history of Colorado.

 

Were you familiar with these Carter Lake hauntings? Would you agree that it is the most haunted Colorado hike? We’d love to read about your experience in the comments section below!

Many hikers love to camp as well. If you have an interest in doing so in an RV, you can learn about it by visiting RVShare. And whether you are new to RVing or are a seasoned pro, here are some great RV tips for your next adventure!

For other terrifying haunts, read 5 Truly Terrifying Ghost Stories That Prove Cripple Creek Is The Most Haunted City In Colorado.

If you’re still in the mood for more Centennial State adventures, take a look at this video:

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Why We Love Colorado

Lysa Allman-Baldwin | July 07, 2023

What are some unique things to do in Colorado?

  • At the Colorado State Capitol you can stand on the 13th step outside and be exactly one mile above sea level.
  • The Pearl Street Mall in Boulder is a unique outdoor mall featuring lots of shops and exciting street performers.
  • The Air Force Academy Visitor Center in Colorado Springs features interesting Air Force related exhibits, a theater, and more.

Read on to learn more about some of the many other unique things to do in Colorado.

Where can we find hidden gems in Colorado?

  • Conundrum Hot Springs in Aspen features natural infinity pools and great hikes in and around the area.
  • The Wheeler Geologic Area features bizarre rock formations created by volcanic ash deposits that are ripe for exploration.
  • Devil's Causeway in Meeker is a 4-foot-wide causeway with dramatic drop-offs that also provide dramatic views.

Read on to learn more about some of the many other hidden gems in Colorado.

Where can we find scenic drives in Colorado?

  • The Last Dollar Road is very popular during the fall for its spectacular foliage displays.
  • The Silver Thread Byway features numerous historic abandoned mining structures.
  • The Trail Ridge Road connecting Estes Park and Grand Lake is a beautiful stretch of U.S. 34 that is also a nationally-designated All American Road.

Read on to learn more about some of the many other amazing scenic drives in Colorado.

Related Articles

Explore Colorado