The Allen House in Monticello, built in 1906, is a lovely work of architecture in the Queen Anne Victorian style. The home itself, however, has a terrifying history.

Originally, local businessman Joe Lee Allen planned for his beautiful house to be Monticello’s showpiece along North Main Street. Allen made sure the home was an eye-catching structure with impressive porch columns and neoclassical design with a touch of gothic decoration. Allen, along with his wife and three daughters, moved into the family home and for a while were content. Allen’s business ventures thrived and all was well until his death in 1917.


In 1949, a tragedy happened that would cast a shadow over the house’s majestic appearance. During the last week of 1948, daughter Ladell Allen poisoned herself after consuming mercury cyanide. The new year would begin on a dark note with Ladell’s death. For nearly 40 years her room was sealed off by her mother. After Mrs. Allen died in 1954, the home was sectioned into apartments and remained a rental property run by the Allen family. Tenants began seeing strange things and experiencing paranormal activity not long after they moved in.

YouTube/Hayley Zagurski

Shadowy figures would appear in photographs taken by residents. Furniture was rearranged with no one having touched anything. Objects around the house would disappear into thin air. The story of Ladell grew into urban legend, and the Allen house was declared haunted by both residents and locals. By the time the 21st-century arrived, the property was under new ownership. Paranormal investigations went on at the property per the approval of the home’s current owners. Multiple “EVP”s (electronic voice phenomenons) were witnessed during the visit. One investigation had to be called off, as a tree branch inexplicably fell as the investigators were visiting the property and slightly damaged their equipment.


The Allen House remains a popular hotspot for ghost hunters and historians. Guided tours are conducted by appointment, and special Halloween tours are conducted annually. Those interested in early 20th-century Arkansas life will want to see the Allen family artifacts and heirlooms that are on display as well. The beauty of the house (despite the urban legend) has even made it a popular spot for weddings. Find out more about how to schedule a tour or event at the Allen house—and beware of Ladell’s spell!

Have you ever visited the Allen House in Monticello? Let us know in the comments below!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

More to Explore

Allen House in Monticello

Are there any haunted mountains in Arkansas?

Shockingly, yes. Just southeast of the Drake Field airport in Fayetteville, Arkansas is a little mountain where in the 1930s, a man came home to his wife and child after a night of drinking. As legend goes, the baby was sick and crying, which angered the man so much that he threw the baby in the well. The mother attempted to save her child and climb down the rope, but the father cut the rope and both mother and baby died. Several reports say that you can still hear the screams of both mother and child.

What are the most haunted places in Arkansas?

Every state has its fair share of haunted places, and Arkansas is no different. Some of the most haunted places in Arkansas include the Arkansas State Capitol, Mount Holly Cemetery in Little Rock, the Toltec Mounds in Scott, Ghost Mountain in Fayetteville, and the Allen House in Monticello. If you’d like to spend the night with a spirit or two, you can always book a stay at the Crescent Hotel & Spa in Eureka Springs, Arkansas. Known as “America’s Most Haunted Hotel,” countless individuals over the last century have reported seeing apparitions, hearing disembodied voices, having possessions moved, and other inexplicable paranormal occurrences.

Are there haunted battlefields in Arkansas?

One of the most haunted battlefields in Arkansas is the Prairie Grove Battlefield located in Prairie Grove, Arkansas. In 1862, Union and Confederate soldiers clashed in a battle that ended with over 2,500 combined casualties. Today, visitors have reported hearing disembodied sounds including horses, cannon fire, and screams. Pea Ridge Battlefield in Garfield is also believed to be haunted by spirits of soldiers from another Union and Confederate battle in 1862. It’s not uncommon for staff and visitors to hear the sounds of drums, musket fire, and a sense that someone is watching them.

Explore Arkansas