Salem is a small town about five miles from the Illinois state line that’s home to one of the most loved spots in all the Midwest. Located not far from the Fox River, it makes sense that there would be a building here dating back to the 1880s that served as a hotel for travelers. It no longer offers rooms for the night, but this gorgeous old building is now home to Siebert’s Pub. There are tons of beautiful old touches left from the building’s previous life, but those are just a bonus when you visit Siebert’s Pub in Wisconsin. You’re really there for the food.

You don't imagine you'll find pub food this good in a town this small, but those who've discovered Siebert's come back again and again. It's clear when you're there that much of the clientele are regulars - locals who know a good thing in their midst when they taste it.
Google Maps
The ubiquitous Wisconsin Friday Fish fry is quite good here and you'll find plenty of people that agree. The cod is crispy and flaky and the servings are huge.
TripAdvisor/Bret R
What people say keeps them coming back is the details. From overflowing mounds of bubbling cheese on the French Onion soup to the various chip, fry and mashed potato options, this is not your regular bar food. It's certainly no dive bar.
TripAdvisor/laurals
The Reuben is so famous it draws folks from across the state line. Those Southern neighbors can't get over the portion sizes and reasonable prices, as well as the killer tap list.
TripAdvisor/corndogsmom

Related Stories

The Oldest Deli In Wisconsin, Kurtz's Pub And Deli Will Take You Straight To Sandwich Heaven

The Oldest Deli In Wisconsin, Kurtz's Pub And Deli Will Take You Straight To Sandwich Heaven

 Sink Your Toes In The Sand At Sand Bar And Island Grill, A One-Of-A-Kind Tiki Bar In Wisconsin

Sink Your Toes In The Sand At Sand Bar And Island Grill, A One-Of-A-Kind Tiki Bar In Wisconsin

 Get Your Bloody Mary Fix At Sobelman’s Pub And Grill, Home Of Wisconsin's Most Outrageous Bloodies  

Get Your Bloody Mary Fix At Sobelman’s Pub And Grill, Home Of Wisconsin's Most Outrageous Bloodies  
The food options are pretty varied here. They all include wonderful touches, like the tasty cheese on the sandwiches or the poppy seed dressing on the wraps. This may be a pub, but the menu is thoughtful and delicious - no one mailed it in here. The choices are all deliberate and delicious.
TripAdvisor/corndogsmom
The Monkey Fries might be the most popular and interesting thing on the menu. This brick is a mass of cheesy delicious goodness. Fries and cheese and bacon are served with a really interesting stout sauce. It's perfectly Wisconsin and oh-so amazing.
Google/DylanGilje
If you're looking for a quirky little out of the way spot with tons of locals, great food, a heck of a beer list and a friendly staff, Siebert's is waiting for you to visit.
TripAdvisor/laurals
You won't go hungry and you'll probably have a hard time deciding which of the delicious menu items to choose, but whatever you end up with, you won't regret it. The food here is so good, the service is even better and you'll be able to understand why folks on multiple different platforms call this some of the very best food in the entire Midwest.
Facebook/SiebertsPub
Siebert's Pub is located at 8403 Antioch Rd, Salem, WI 53168. To learn more, visit their Facebook page here.

Have you ever eaten at Sieberts Pub in Wisconsin? What’s your favorite thing on the menu? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below! And if you know another hidden gem we should feature, nominate it on our online form here.

It turns out the area just north of the state line is full of small town restaurants that will delight. For more excellent eats, check out our previous article: This Tiny Wisconsin Diner In The Middle Of Nowhere Serves Food So Good You Won’t Mind The Drive.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Siebert's Pub in Wisconsin

Elisa Regulski | May 17, 2020

What are the best pubs in Wisconsin?

Looking for the best pubs in Wisconsin? There’s no shortage of amazing places to enjoy a meal and a pint. Revere’s Wells Street Tavern, located in Delafield, is one of the highest rated. You’ll love their exceptional burgers, pastas, and sandwiches, but it’s their giant pretzels that keep people coming back for more. Gather your closest friends and share this delicious treat together. The homemade cheese dipping sauce is absolutely amazing.

What are the best places to get comfort food in Wisconsin?

You’ll find tons of mouthwatering comfort food in Wisconsin. For some sweet homemade pies, head over to Crystal Cafe in Iola. You’ll love the welcoming atmosphere and scrumptious eats. Apple Holler, located in Sturtevant, is another fantastic place to satisfy your comfort food cravings. Enjoy crispy fried chicken, ooey grilled cheese sandwiches, and buttery biscuits and gravy. Nothing beats this wonderful eatery. For more amazing comfort food in Wisconsin, try the 11 best grilled cheese sandwiches in the state. You can’t go wrong at any of these mouthwatering dining destinations.

What are the oldest bars in Wisconsin?

Brossman's Bar, located in Franksville, is one of the oldest bars in Wisconsin. In fact, this place has been around since before Wisconsin was a state! If you want to enjoy delicious meals in a historic atmosphere, this is the place to go. Some even say this place is haunted. Keep your eye out for spectral visions of the former owner. Ghost enthusiasts believe this place is so beloved, some visitors return to visit from beyond the grave.

Related Articles

Explore Wisconsin

Featured Addresses
8403 Antioch Rd, Salem, WI 53168, USA