Based in Mukwonago since 1946, the Elegant Farmer is a Wisconsin institution. They offer everything from fruit picking to a corn maze, so their parking lot is full pretty much every weekend. But what they’re most famous for is their Apple Pie in a Bag. They say the method of baking in a paper bag creates a unique crunchy top crust and a light, flaky old fashioned bottom crust. The Food Network, Gourmet Magazine, The Wall Street Journal and 70 years of customers have called it the best apple pie in Wisconsin.


Have you ever tried the best apple pie in Wisconsin? Tell us about it in the comments! And if you know another incredible bakery in the Dairy State, nominate it for a chance to be featured.

Looking for more sweet stuff? Check out our previous article: You’ve Never Tasted Anything Like These 10 Unique Desserts In Wisconsin

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

More to Explore

best apple pie in Wisconsin

What are the best farms in Wisconsin?

There are so many lovely farms in Wisconsin. For a scenic day trip, venture to Rowley Creek Lavender Farm. This stunning destination is both eye-caching and fragrant. You’ll love strolling through the grounds and drinking in the views. If you’re looking for something sweet, pay a visit to Oakwood Fruit Farm in Richland Center. This pastoral destination sits on 180 acres of land, there’s so much to discover. Take home fresh apples, grapes, and pumpkins! They also make some of the most mouthwatering sweet treats around. You’ll fall in love with their donuts.

What are the best small town restaurants in Wisconsin?

Some of the best eateries are tucked inside small towns. For some truly hearty comfort food, visit Sheila Mae’s Town Fryer in Burlington. This bright eatery will make you feel right at home. For some fresh seafood, head over to Little Village Café in Baraboo. Looking for more dining ideas? Check out our list of the best small town restaurants in Wisconsin. Each restaurant on this list is certain to impress you.

What are the best bakeries in Wisconsin?

For some comforting sweet treats, visit Pleasant View Bakery in Dalton. This traditional Amish bakery is known for its giant cinnamon rolls, but that’s just the beginning. Dig into a slice of their excellent lemon meringue pie, pretzels, and pecan tarts. No matter what you order, you’re going to love it. Smurawa’s Country Bakery, located in Pulaski, is another fantastic place to get baked goods in Wisconsin. Stop by on a Sunday and try their hot ham rolls. Or, kick off your morning with one of their colorful sweet pastries!

Explore Wisconsin