There’s truly nothing better than a Wisconsin supper club. These fabulous restaurants are a part of what makes this state great and it seems everyone has a favorite. The best part, though, is that there always seems to be another historic club to discover and fall in love with. Though we tend to think of hidden clubs in small towns, one of the best ones is actually right in Madison. They serve up all the classics and they have prices that will make both you and your wallet extremely happy!

Toby's is that perfect amount of retro that you really want in a supper club. It's cozy and welcoming and feels like the kind of place you want to hang out and return to again and again. These folks have been serving up amazing fish, steak, old fashioneds, and their signature Key Lime Martini for more than 50 years.
Facebook/TobysSupperClub
Start your night off with an old fashioned or any drink of choice. You're here to kick back and relax, and these folks are going to treat you right. There's a full bar to mix up whatever you're feeling that night.
TripAdvisor/MarieMatteson
You can treat yourself to a drink (or a few) because a trip to Toby's doesn't even come close to breaking the bank. The prices here are so reasonable that you'll find them hard to believe. At lunch, the sandwiches are under $8 and the most expensive dinner is the 12 oz NY Strip at just $22.95. The kids menu is all $5, ice cream is $2.50 and the burger is just $7.
TripAdvisor/Jfadds

Related Stories

Wine And Dine At This Renovated Schoolhouse In A Tiny Wisconsin Town

Wine And Dine At This Renovated Schoolhouse In A Tiny Wisconsin Town

 There's Years Of Brewing History Hiding In This Tiny Wisconsin Town

There's Years Of Brewing History Hiding In This Tiny Wisconsin Town

 Dine At These 18 Extremely Tiny Restaurants In Wisconsin That Are Actually Amazing

Dine At These 18 Extremely Tiny Restaurants In Wisconsin That Are Actually Amazing
All dinners come with a salad, choice of potato, relish and rolls. This is the full supper club experience and treatment and, of course, it's all delicious. They've perfected it all in their decades in business and you get to benefit.
Google/KitriBussey
The steaks start with a $13 sirloin that's juicy, tender and so darn good your tastebuds will throw a party. Add onions or bleu cheese or sauteed mushrooms to make it a truly decadent and amazing meal.
Google/DonaldRosby
You won't be disappointed in anything you order from Toby's. The menu is classic and scrumptious and perfect for your pocketbook.
TripAdvisor/WeKick
Toby's is a quintessential Wisconsin supper club. You'll love meeting with friends, having a drink or two and relaxing in a wonderfully welcoming environment. There's a reason these folks have been in business longer than a lot of us have been alive. It's the perfect place to unwind at the end of the week!
TripAdvisor/CubsWSChamps

Address: 3717 S Dutch Mill Road, Madison, WI, 53718.

Learn more about this fabulous supper club and check out the menu on their website.

Toby’s is open for lunch Monday through Friday from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. They’re open for dinner on Monday and Tuesday from 5 p.m. to 9 p.m., Wednesday, Thursday, and Saturday from 5 p.m. to 10 p.m. and Friday from 5 p.m. to 10:30 p.m. They are close on Sundays.

If you love discovering supper clubs, check out these off-the-radar spots you’re going to love!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Wisconsin