10 Wisconsin Supper Clubs That Are Old-Fashioned But Incredible
If you haven’t lived in Wisconsin, you probably have no idea what a supper club is. It’s one of those things that is very difficult to explain to out-of-towners, even if you successfully describe the ambiance and food. You have to experience it to really understand it. Supper clubs are a dying breed, which is sad, because we’ve turned to quick food from chain restaurants rather than supporting these great places. Take a night off from cooking, get gussied up, and head to one of these 10 old-fashioned supper clubs in Wisconsin. (And then take a look at part 2 of our Wisconsin supper club round-up.)
We’re aware that these uncertain times are limiting many aspects of life. While we continue to feature destinations that make our state wonderful, please take proper precautions or add them to your bucket list to see at a later date. If you know of a local business that could use some extra support during these times, please nominate them here: onlyinyourstate.com/nominate
The Buckhorn Supper Club is located in Milton, Wisconsin, on Charley's Bluff to be specific. It is right off of Lake Koshkonong. The supper club has been in operation for eighty years. If you're a fan of lobster boil, check them out - they often whip up scrumptious seafood feasts. People love to stop by for the cod, and the prime rib never disappoints. To learn more, visit Buckhorn Supper Club's website.
Located in New Holstein, Schwarz's has been in business for over fifty years. It started out as a simple, one-room tavern and has expanded to accommodate a growing amount of guests. You'll love their steaks, all of which are cut in-house and adorned with a secret blend of seasoning. People love the Friday Night Perch Fry, but seafood enthusiasts can have their fill of fresh seafood any day of the week. To learn more, visit the website for Schwarz's Supper Club.
You will love Ding-A-Ling Supper Club, a restaurant with a family-friendly atmosphere. So why should you travel off the beaten path to eat here? Meat. Specifically, steaks, prime rib, and BBQ ribs that rival anyone's. And if you haven't thoroughly stuffed your face, you need to have an after-dinner ice cream drink. And then you might need to get a hotel there and a bigger pair of pants. Visit Ding-A-Ling Supper Club's Facebook page to learn more.
Out in Sherwood, the Granary is a hopping place but manages to still give that personalized experience to its guests. You will get a very nice steak. And surprisingly, people rave about the salad bar. That's high praise, because when people are faced with the choice of meat and vegetables, we know which way most of them go. Visit The Granary Supper Club's website to learn more.
In Clintonville, Lake Aire Supper Club is a great place to get a meal, if just for the view. The supper club is perched on a hill overlooking a small lake. Watch a glorious Wisconsin sunset. You will get a classic Wisconsin supper club experience here. Great steaks, potatoes. And head to the salad bar for hot bacon dressing (what?!) and those classic cheese spreads our state is known for. Come and experience one of the best old-fashioned supper clubs in Wisconsin!
Over in Trempealeau, a beautiful town offering amazing views, is a classic Wisconsin supper club. Can we talk a little more about the location? Your backdrop is the Mississippi River! People love to take those drinks out on the deck and enjoy the view. Sullivan's has been serving up food that stands up to the backdrop, however, since 1968. King Crab? Yes, please. Irish Handshake? Phenomenal. (I guess in Ireland, tenderloin tips and scallops shake hands. How polite.) To learn more, visit the website for Sullivan's Supper Club.
This Supper Club is located in Kiel, and unlike many supper clubs, you don't have to eat the same thing every time you come here. That's because the menu is chef-driven and there are new choices each week. And those choices are awesome, including classics like choice steaks and fresh seafood, but also some good pasta dishes. Don't miss the great salad bar, which features some good soups (made from scratch, of course). To learn more, visit the website for Millhome Supper Club.
It's time to head over to Oshkosh for a phenomenal fine dining experience. Roxy has been serving the area for over 50 years, and the reason they've been so popular is two-fold: great service and excellent quality. Yes, you will get that classic Wisconsin supper club experience with the best steak around. But consider stopping by for Sunday brunch. Ever had a shrimp and crab omelette? Well, you can, but only at the Roxy. To learn more, visit The Roxy Supper Club's website.
Maiden Lake has been a mainstay in Wisconsin's Northwoods for over 30 years. What's good? Definitely what you would expect from a great supper club, including some wonderful surf and turf dishes. Friday is FISH DAY and you'll be happy you are at Maiden Lake to partake. And they serve up a good relish tray, which is always a great touch. To learn more, visit Maiden Lake Supper Club's website.
Arthur's is another reason to come to scenic Spring Green. They've been serving up delicious and classic Wisconsin fare since 1966, using locally sourced ingredients like Angus Beef and real Wisconsin cheese. Friday is fish fry day, Saturday is prime rib, and Sunday is turkey dinner. Need we say more? Oh, and if you just want to drink in a great atmosphere, head here for the bar. And drink an Old Fashioned. For tradition. For more information, visit the website for Arthur's Supper Club.
Have you eaten at any of these old-fashioned supper clubs in Wisconsin? Which one is your favorite? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below! And if we left off your favorite restaurant, nominate it for a chance to be featured in a future article.
Supper clubs aren’t the only things we’re known for. If you’re looking for even more fun, check out these iconic bars in Wisconsin.
Address: 11802 N Charley Bluff Rd, Milton, WI 53563, USA
Address: W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061, USA
Address: 8215 W Race St, Orfordville, WI 53576, USA
Address: N586 Military Rd, Sherwood, WI 54169, USA
Address: County Hwy Y, Clintonville, WI 54929, USA
Address: W25709 Sullivan Rd, Trempealeau, WI 54661, USA
Address: 16524 Lax Chapel Rd, Kiel, WI 53042, USA
Address: 571 N Main St, Oshkosh, WI 54901, USA
Address: 15649 Maiden Lake Rd, Mountain, WI 54149, USA
Address: E4885 US-14, Spring Green, WI 53588, USA
The OIYS Visitor Center
old-fashioned supper clubs in Wisconsin
November 23, 2020
Elisa Regulski
What is a Wisconsin supper club?
In general, supper clubs are independently-owned restaurants that are only open during dinnertime. Their menus are usually limited, and they often feature steak dishes and classic cocktails. If you really want the classic Wisconsin supper club experience, you have to order a hearty steak and a refreshing old fashioned.
What are the best small town supper clubs in Wisconsin?
There are so many delicious small town supper clubs in Wisconsin. Silvercryst Supper Club, located in Wautoma, is a must-visit. This place doesn’t just serve scrumptious dishes – they also offer a magnificent view. Nestled between two lakes, this Wisconsin supper club will give you a meal you’ll never forget. Want to learn more? Check out our full list of the best small town supper clubs in Wisconsin.
What kind of food is Wisconsin known for?
When most people think about food in Wisconsin, their mind immediately pictures cheese. Of course, this isn’t the only thing we are known for! If you want to learn more, read our full article about the most delicious, iconic foods in Wisconsin.
Address: 11802 N Charley Bluff Rd, Milton, WI 53563, USA
Address: W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061, USA
Address: 8215 W Race St, Orfordville, WI 53576, USA
Address: N586 Military Rd, Sherwood, WI 54169, USA
Address: County Hwy Y, Clintonville, WI 54929, USA
Address: W25709 Sullivan Rd, Trempealeau, WI 54661, USA
Address: 16524 Lax Chapel Rd, Kiel, WI 53042, USA
Address: 571 N Main St, Oshkosh, WI 54901, USA
Address: 15649 Maiden Lake Rd, Mountain, WI 54149, USA
Address: E4885 US-14, Spring Green, WI 53588, USA
Love exploring Wisconsin restaurants?
Thank you! You'll receive your first newsletter soon!
