As if there weren’t already enough things to love about Wisconsin, we found another: the ice cream sundae. Over the years, various places have claimed to be the home of the classic treat; however, it turns out that E.C. Berners’ Ice Cream Parlor in Two Rivers has been deemed the true creator. Read on for the full scoop on this historic ice cream parlor in Wisconsin.

The ice cream sundae can have only one birthplace – and it’s Two Rivers. More specifically, the very first sundae was served at E.C. Berners’ Ice Cream Parlor in 1881.
Washington House Museum and Visitor's Center/Facebook
Though several other cities, including Evanston, IL and Ithaca, NY claim to be the birthplace of the sundae, several historians have weighed in, declaring Two Rivers the true birthplace of the tasty treat.
Heather Zepczyk/Google
Edward C. Berners’ soda fountain and ice cream parlor operated on the first floor of a 2-story building in Two Rivers. Interestingly enough, the iconic concoction wasn’t actually Berners’ idea.
wisconsinhistory.org
As the story goes, Berners’ friend, George Hallauer, asked for the unique dessert. Apparently, Hallauer noticed a bottle of chocolate syrup, which was normally used for ice cream sodas, and thought it would be a great addition to his ice cream. Berners was initially hesitant because he thought it would ruin the flavor of the ice cream, but, lucky for us, he gave in.
Berners liked the chocolate-topped ice cream so much that he added it to his menu, charging a nickel for the deliciously sweet treat. Eventually, other ice cream parlors followed suit.
Washington House Museum and Visitor's Center/Facebook
There are several theories behind the name sundae. However, many contribute the moniker to the fact that many parlors offered the treat only on Sundays since the 5¢ price tag was well below what it cost to actually make a sundae.

Related Stories

With Its Own Private Playground, This Incredible Cafe In Wisconsin Is Perfect For Families

With Its Own Private Playground, This Incredible Cafe In Wisconsin Is Perfect For Families

 This Speakeasy Hidden In An Old Harness Shop In Wisconsin Is Perfect For A Date Night

This Speakeasy Hidden In An Old Harness Shop In Wisconsin Is Perfect For A Date Night

 I Toured A Cheese Museum In Wisconsin Because Of Course I Did

I Toured A Cheese Museum In Wisconsin Because Of Course I Did
Sadly, Berners’ Ice Cream Parlor was demolished in 1979. Luckily, there’s a replica of the famous ice cream parlor in the Washington House.
Jack Gadzala/Google
Historic in its own right, the Washington House was built in 1850 and originally served as a hotel and tavern.
Washington House Museum and Visitor's Center/Facebook
Today, the interior of the Washington House includes several unique pieces of the past, including an 1890s saloon and ballroom. However, the ice cream parlor continues to be a favorite of many.
Rod Tadlock/Google
Like stepping back in time, the sweet shop’s walls are adorned with photos of the original Berners. It's also filled with vintage furniture and decor.
Carol Hobson-Payne/Google
But the best part about the ice cream parlor is that it’s fully-functioning, which means you can enjoy a sundae in an old-fashioned ice cream parlor that sits just blocks from where the very first sundae was made all those years ago.
Debbie Cracraft/Google
For more information on the Washington House, call (920) 793-2490. You can also visit the Washington House website or Facebook page.

Have you ever tried the tasty treats at The Washington House in Wisconsin? If so, we want to hear all about your experience! Share your thoughts with us in the comments below. And if you know another must-visit attraction in the Dairy State, nominate it for a chance to be featured.

This isn’t the only historic ice cream parlor in Wisconsin. For more nostalgic treats, visit this charming ice cream shop in East Troy.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

historic ice cream parlor in Wisconsin

Elisa Regulski | July 30, 2020

Where can I find the best ice cream in Wisconsin?

As America’s Dairyland, it’s no surprise that Wisconsin whips up scrumptious ice cream treats. If you’re looking for some of the best desserts around, we recommend taking this fun and delicious ice cream road trip through Wisconsin. This sweet adventure begins at Purple Door in Milwaukee, a beloved ice cream parlor known for their inventive flavors. Be sure to try their whiskey flavored ice cream! It’s truly incredible. Then, you’ll venture to Gilles Frozen Custard and try their perfect sundae. Bring your appetite, because this is just the beginning of this epic road trip.

What are the best historic destinations in Wisconsin?

Let’s keep the excitement going with this short road trip to Wisconsin’s most fascinating historic attractions. On your journey, you’ll learn all about the Big Top at the Circus World Museum in Baraboo. Then, you’ll stop by Frank Lloyd Wright’s stunning estate, Taliesin. After that, venture to Pendarvis in Mineral Point. You’ll love exploring the mining history of this artsy area.

What are the most notable inventions in Wisconsin?

The ice cream sundae isn’t the only thing that was invented in Wisconsin. In fact, our state is home to a slew of amazing creators. The blender, steam-powered vehicle, and clothes dryer were all born in the Dairy State! Want to learn more? Check out our full list of the most notable things that came from Wisconsin.

Related Articles

Featured Addresses
1622 Jefferson St, Two Rivers, WI 54241, USA