Urban legends have all the allure of traditional storytelling and folklore, with the added bonus that they are situated in your exact time and place. When you hear them, you know they’re probably not true… But that doesn’t keep you from walking a little faster past the cemetery or avoiding the darkest corner of your attic. If you’re in the mood for a chill or you need some fodder to creep out your little sister, you’ve come to the right place for Pennsylvania urban legends.

Related Stories

The Little-Known Story Of The American Marten In Pennsylvania And How It May Be Making A Comeback

The Little-Known Story Of The American Marten In Pennsylvania And How It May Be Making A Comeback

Visit Turtle Falls In Pennsylvania, A Hidden Gem Along A Scenic Path

Visit Turtle Falls In Pennsylvania, A Hidden Gem Along A Scenic Path

We'll Choose Snacks And Apps Over Dinner Any Day At This Pennsylvania Restaurant

We'll Choose Snacks And Apps Over Dinner Any Day At This Pennsylvania Restaurant

These aren’t the only Pennsylvania urban legends— in fact there are scary tales from all over the states. Do any rumors keep you up at night? Let us know in the comments below!

Looking for more scary stories? Check out these haunted hotels in Pennsylvania.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Pennsylvania Urban Legends

What is the most famous Pennsylvania urban legend?

One of the most famous urban legends in Pennsylvania is the legend of the "Philadelphia Experiment." The Philadelphia Experiment is a story alleging a secret U.S. Navy experiment in Philadelphia during World War II. According to the legend, the experiment aimed to render the USS Eldridge, a naval destroyer escort, invisible to radar. However, it is believed that the experiment went awry, resulting in the ship disappearing and reappearing and some crew members experiencing adverse effects like disorientation and illness.

The story gained widespread attention and notoriety after being publicized in a series of books and later popularized by the 1984 film "The Philadelphia Experiment." The legend has captivated the imaginations of conspiracy theorists and those interested in paranormal phenomena. However, it's important to note that the Philadelphia Experiment has been widely debunked by experts and is considered a work of fiction or a hoax.

What is the scariest Pennsylvania urban legend?

One of the scariest urban legends in Pennsylvania is the legend of the "Allegewi." According to the legend, the Allegewi were a powerful and ancient Native American tribe that once inhabited the region before the arrival of European settlers. The Allegewi were known for their size, strength, and mystical powers.

The legend states that the Allegewi were not pleased with the encroachment of the settlers and unleashed their wrath upon them. They used their supernatural abilities to create treacherous traps, mysterious disappearances, and deadly illusions to protect their territory.

The Allegewi are said to have the ability to control the weather, summon spirits, and transform into fearsome creatures. Their presence was marked by eerie sounds, whispers in the wind, and sightings of shadowy figures lurking in the forests.

The Allegewi legend continues to instill fear and fascination among those who hear it. While the existence of the Allegewi tribe is steeped in myth and mystery, the eerie tales surrounding them contribute to the unsettling allure of this Pennsylvania urban legend.