Bigger isn’t always better…but in the case of milkshakes it is! And if you agree, a visit to Extreme Creamy won’t disappoint. Aptly named, the sweet shop serves up milkshakes that are equal parts massive and creative. The over-the-top treats are sure to make a lasting impression on you and your sweet tooth. Take a look:

Tucked away in an unassuming strip mall in Lancaster, you’ll find Extreme Creamery.
google.com
Opened at the end of 2019, the sweet shop is still practically a secret, but it won’t be for long…
Rebecca Frost/Google
…and that’s because it’s home to some of the biggest and best milkshakes in Ohio.
Jessica Smith/Google
Dubbed Extreme Shakes, the over-the-top milkshakes definitely live up to their name.
Extreme Creamery/Facebook
Piled high with creative topping combinations, the massive shakes are like something from a sweet dream.
Extreme Creamery/Facebook
Cookies, cakes, pastries, cereal, fruit, and candies are just a few of the goodies used to take the milkshakes from ordinary to extraordinary.
Extreme Creamery/Facebook

Related Stories

Treat Yourself To Soft Serve Ice Cream At Zip Dip, A 1950s Ohio Snack Shop

Treat Yourself To Soft Serve Ice Cream At Zip Dip, A 1950s Ohio Snack Shop

 This Massive Candy Store In Ohio Will Take You Right Back To Childhood

This Massive Candy Store In Ohio Will Take You Right Back To Childhood

 Treat Yourself To A Little Piece Of Italy Right Here In Ohio At Stella Mia Ristorante

Treat Yourself To A Little Piece Of Italy Right Here In Ohio At Stella Mia Ristorante
Of course, there are a few typical toppings, like sprinkles, too.
Extreme Creamery/Facebook
Regardless of the toppings used, the end result is creative concoctions, like The Cookie Monster.
Extreme Creamery/Facebook
There are also seasonal and specialty flavors, such as The Grinch.
Extreme Creamery/Facebook
Don’t think you can handle an Extreme Shake? No problem; the sweet shop also serves up standard sized shakes – regular (12 oz) and large (20 oz).
Extreme Creamery/Facebook
Not craving a shake? That’s not a problem either. Browse the menu and you’ll find rolled ice cream as well as scoopable ice cream.
Extreme Creamery/Facebook
So, are you ready to treat yourself with a visit to Extreme Creamery?
Extreme Creamery/Facebook

Extreme Creamery is open Sundays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays, from 2 p.m. – 9 p.m., and Friday – Saturday, from 2 p.m. – 10 p.m. For more information, call (740) 785-5080. You can also visit the Extreme Creamery Facebook page.

So, did you know about Extreme Creamery? Ever visited? Did you try one of the shakes? If so, what’d you think? Tell us in the comments section.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Ohio

Featured Addresses
726 N Memorial Dr, Lancaster, OH 43130, USA