This Off-The-Beaten Path Eatery In Ohio Is Known For Its Mouthwatering Peanut Butter Pie
By Melissa Mahoney|Published October 02, 2022
×
Melissa Mahoney
Author
I'm an east coast girl living in a west coast world. I've worked in the entertainment industry for much of my adult life and I love photography, writing, and traveling around the U.S. as well as to far-flung locations around the world! Travel is my life and writing about it is a dream.
How would you like to eat like a local? There’s an off-the-beaten-path eatery in Ohio that’s been around for nearly a century and it’s a place where the locals come to eat. Boyd & Wurthmann in Berlin offers a menu filled with diner favorites, but the one thing people can’t get enough of is the pie, especially the peanut butter pie. If you love peanut butter and pie in general, make plans to visit this Holmes County establishment.
Located in Berlin in the heart of Ohio's Amish country, Boyd & Wurthmann is a no-frills eatery that offers delicious home-cooked Amish and American cuisine. It's been open since 1938, making it a long-standing business in the area.
This restaurant opens its doors bright and early for breakfast. Get ready for some eggs, fluffy pancakes, homemade sausage gravy and biscuits, and more to start your day.
For lunch and dinner, you'll have your choice of something light like a salad or the marinated grilled chicken breast entree, a burger, a patty melt, or any other number of deliciously satisfying dishes.
If you're someone who loves pie (and who doesn't?), you'll LOVE the pie here a Boyd & Wurthmann. Order a slice of homemade pie on its own or with ice cream - you can't go wrong either way!
One flavor of pie that both new and regular customers rave about is the peanut butter pie. You've never had anything satisfy your sweet tooth quite like this before.
And it's so good on its own that you probably won't even need to order it à la mode.
Another delectable option Boyd & Wurthmann may have during your visit is the peanut butter cup cheesecake. With its perfect combination of peanut butter and chocolate flavors, this is another must-try dessert here.
Have you ever dined at this off-the-beaten-path eatery in Ohio? Did you have a slice of peanut butter pie? Let us know in the comments! To learn more about the restaurant, including location, hours of operation, and the menu, visit the Boyd & Wurthmann website and Facebook page. ((Please note: it is cash only here.)
Did you know that the town of Berlin is an Amish town in Ohio that’s worth exploring? And we think you should dine at Boyd & Wurthmann while you’re here!
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
