How would you like to eat like a local? There’s an off-the-beaten-path eatery in Ohio that’s been around for nearly a century and it’s a place where the locals come to eat. Boyd & Wurthmann in Berlin offers a menu filled with diner favorites, but the one thing people can’t get enough of is the pie, especially the peanut butter pie. If you love peanut butter and pie in general, make plans to visit this Holmes County establishment.

Have you ever dined at this off-the-beaten-path eatery in Ohio? Did you have a slice of peanut butter pie? Let us know in the comments! To learn more about the restaurant, including location, hours of operation, and the menu, visit the Boyd & Wurthmann website and Facebook page. ((Please note: it is cash only here.)

Did you know that the town of Berlin is an Amish town in Ohio that’s worth exploring? And we think you should dine at Boyd & Wurthmann while you’re here!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Explore Ohio