No matter where you reside in our state, it’s never too difficult to find a good spot to eat at when you live in a place like New York. A statement that holds true out in Erie County, the small town of East Aurora is one of our favorite dining destinations. Just a quick 5-minute drive from outdoor adventures like Knox Farm State Park, there’s an incredible bakery that’s the perfect place to stop while you’re exploring in the area.

Just a quick half-hour drive from the city of Buffalo, the small town of East Aurora has a population of roughly 6,000 residents.
Google Maps
With plenty of great local shops worth checking out in the area, Elm Street Bakery stands out amongst them all.
Google Maps
As soon as you make your way inside the bakery you'll smell all of the reasons why you're going to love eating at this place.
Ganna K./Yelp
Besides their wonderful patio out front, visitors of Elm Street Bakery can also choose to dine upstairs where the ambiance is perfectly cozy.
Stan F./Yelp
Giving you a bird's eye view of what sweets lie down below, guests dining upstairs will be able to gaze upon the heavenly variety of bakery items that Elm Street puts its own unique and creative spin on.
Dan V./Yelp
From pies and macaroons to cheesecakes and cookies, your sweet tooth will be doing its best to convince you to order one of everything while you're here.
Analisa L./Yelp
Open for Breakfast, Lunch and Dinner, this farm-to-table eatery also has much more to offer than the expected pastry items.
Elise S./Yelp
Putting their oven to work, the bakery draws in hungry guests from all over the state who are wanting to see what their seasonal menus are all about.
Hania A./Yelp
Out of all the things you'll find listed on their lunch and dinner menus, possibly the most satisfying thing to order is their wood-fired pizzas.
Hania A./Yelp
Comprised of homemade dough, sauce and fresh mozzarella, these pizzas taste nothing like the average pies that you'll generally stumble upon.
Ralph C/TripAdvisor
Open every day of the week except for Mondays, you can view the bakery's current bread schedule if you click here.
Julia M./Yelp
If you've never visited Elm Street Bakery, let us give you some more insight! The bakery operates without a waiter service for both breakfast and lunch, turning into a full-service restaurant at 5PM for dinner. Inside, you're constantly surrounded by delicious dishes but you'll discover that there's a separate counter for bakery items that will be calling out to your heart.

Another thing you'll love about this bakery is that they have their own market with an assortment of goods that you'll positively want to take home with you. If you're interested in finding out more information, click here.

How to get here: 72 Elm Street East Aurora, NY 14052

What do you love to order from Elm Street Bakery? Feel free to leave pictures of your favorite treats from this shop in our comments section! To give your taste buds another ride of their life, head to The Bakery On This Beautiful Farm In New York That You Absolutely Have To Visit.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Related Articles

Explore New York