When you’re looking for a perfect date night option in the Garden State, you really must book a table at one of the following romantic restaurants in New Jersey. Of course, whatever atmosphere it is you’re looking for, there’s most certainly a restaurant in New Jersey that will have you covered! With a plethora of dining options, it isn’t hard to find the perfect place to meet your needs. We’ve got mom and pop joints, retro gems, historic hot spots, and so much more, but if you’re looking for romance, look no further than these fantastic restaurants in New Jersey

What’s your pick for most romantic eatery in New Jersey? If casual dining is more your scene, check out these 12 teeny tiny restaurants In New Jersey or these 15 awesome brunch spots.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

More to Explore

Romantic restaurants in New Jersey

What are the best date night restaurants in New Jersey?

For those looking for a more casual date night spot than the above list of romantic restaurants in New Jersey offers, we recommend checking out these craft breweries in the Garden State. Because what's more romantic than a local brew in an outdoor biergarten, complete with live music twinkle lights? Nothing, we say. Don’t believe us? Well, you need to spend some time at one of New Jersey’s many fantastic breweries, like Cape May Brewing Co., Twin Elephant, or Icarus Brewing. Need more suggestions? We also love 902 Brewing, where you can often catch music and other live events. At Twin Elephant Brewing Company, you'll find a wide variety of fresh, handcrafted ales and lagers; while Hackensack Brewing boasts an outdoor biergarten, indoor tap room, and plenty of amazing beers! For more date night ideas, we recommend checking out this list of 12 bucket-list worthy restaurants in New Jersey, which feature some lovely seasonal spots that maximize the beauty of the Garden State! 

What's *the* most romantic restaurant in New Jersey?

While the above 13 options are all super romantic, swoon-worthy restaurants in New Jersey that really will take your date night to the next level, there's one that we just simply can't resist. Of course, we're talking about Scarborough Fair Restaurant, the most unique, lovely, and romantic restaurant in all of New Jersey. Not simply a place do dine; Scarborough Fair really is an entire experience. A farmhouse from the 1850s until the 1970s, this eatery is overflowing with rustic charm. It offers unique multi-level dining and a few very special features. You'll find a magnificent menu offering options like steak and seafood. Their menu is best described as "New American" but they also offer delicious dishes from around the world. They "source the finest and freshest locally grown, sustainable and organic ingredients." And, they "use humanely raised organic meats and poultry, wild fish and shellfish or purchase fresh from local fisheries." The raw bar is a favorite and you'll also want to check out the wine list... raw oysters and wine? Talk about setting the mood for romance!