Some interesting legends exist in the Garden State. The Jersey Devil is, of course, iconic. Anyone who has ever wondered about our woods (particularly in the Pine Barrens) is familiar with the tale. But we’ve got other legends that are perhaps even more chilling. And here are 3 tales from the most haunted places in New Jersey that will give you nightmares.

Jenny Jump Mountain is a 1,112-foot high, six-mile-long ridge.
Wikipedia/Famartin
While scenic, the stories behind its name are quite melancholy. Legend has it that a young girl was picking berries when she was startled by a Native American. Whether she was actually in danger, we'll never know. Either way, her father seemed to be concerned for her safety. He yelled out, Jenny, jump (presumably into his arms). Unfortunately, she fell to her death. To this day, many report seeing the spirit of a young girl wandering the area...looking for someone to catch her.

Related Stories

8 Waterfront Retreats In New Jersey That Are Perfect For Warm Weather Adventures

8 Waterfront Retreats In New Jersey That Are Perfect For Warm Weather Adventures

 You Can Get A Fresh-Baked Pastry In The Drive-Thru At This Quaint Eatery In New Jersey

You Can Get A Fresh-Baked Pastry In The Drive-Thru At This Quaint Eatery In New Jersey

 Visit The Heart of Revolutionary War History In New Jersey At Old Barracks Museum

Visit The Heart of Revolutionary War History In New Jersey At Old Barracks Museum
Nestled among the mountains is Ghost Lake.
Flickr/Stephen Harris
The beautiful lake offers opportunities for both boating and fishing, but several spooky stories surround it. Visitors report frequent fog, despite the weather and seeing spirits arise from the mist. While the lake likely got its name from the vapor shimmering over the surface on cooler days, some claim that horrific murders took place in the area.

Then, there are those who believe that the lake lies atop a sacred Native American burial ground. There's also a small cave near the lake, now called the Fairy Hole, which is believed to be on sacred ground. The cave is not open to the public but is an interesting site as archaeologists found Native American artifacts in it when they surveyed the cave back in 1918.
And right alongside Jenny Jump...Shades of Death Road.
Wikipedia/Daniel Case
How did it get its name? Some speculate the seclusion of the area made it a popular spot for highway robberies. Others say that many Native Americans were drowned in nearby Ghost Lake and their spirits still walk the street. This is unlikely, as the lake has not existed that long. A third theory is that a malaria outbreak in the area which killed hundreds led to the road traveling through the town being given the foreboding name.

Other possibilities include roaming wildcats in the former swampland mauling travelers along this path, the danger of the dark and winding road, and frequent lynchings of criminals on the trees surrounding the street. However, it's just as likely that the road got its name thanks to the trees that line it, creating constant shade.

Do you believe the stories about these haunted places in New Jersey? What others have you heard? And here’s an article about another chilling (but scenic) spot in New Jersey

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

HAUNTED PLACES IN NEW JERSEY & RELATED INFO

Melanie J. | December 30, 2022

What is there to do at Jenny Jump State Park?

While Jenny Jump State Park is perhaps most famous for the legend that surrounds it, the park is a stunning place, boasting sweeping vistas of the Highlands and the Kittatinny Mountains as well as the scenic valley to the west. There are tons to do at this park and they include:

  • Boating, fishing, kayaking, and canoeing are just a few of the water recreational activities that you can experience at Jenny Jump State Park.
  • Hiking is by far one of the most popular activities at Jenny Jump State Park. And with 14 miles of trails, it’s guaranteed there will be incredible scenic landscapes. 
  • Camping is popular at the park and it offers 22 tent and trailer sites with shower amenities. They are available from April to October 31st.
  • Picnicking is a fun activity that the entire family can enjoy, and there are a few tables as well as grills at the park. So, pack a basket and bring the family along for a fun-filled day. 
  • Bird Watching is popular amongst nature enthusiasts, and Jenny Jump State Park is a haven for many species of birds as well as wildlife. Bring the camera and enjoy all the park has to offer.

Here’s a previous article telling you more about Jenny Jump State Park in New Jersey. 

Besides the Jenny Jump State Park legend, what are some more haunted places in New Jersey?

It is safe to say that there are no shortages of haunted places in New Jersey. In fact, due to the state’s history of tragedy, there are tons of haunted places to explore. Some of the most haunted places in New Jersey are:

  • The Devil's Tree
  • Hindenburg Hangar 
  • The Spy House
  • The Emlen Physick Estate
  • Pine Barrens Reserve
  • Snake Hill
  • Historic Village at Allaire
  • Shippen Manor
  • The Gateway To Hell
  • Greystone Psychiatric Hospital

And here’s a previous article about one of the most haunted places in New Jersey. 

Related Articles

Featured Addresses
Jenny Jump Mountain, White, NJ 07823, USA
Ghost Lake, Great Meadows, NJ 07838, USA
Shades of Death Road, Shades of Death Rd, New Jersey, USA