Posted in New Jersey American, Food & Dining, Iconic Foods, Seafood & Steak March 06, 2023 by Raymond Goldfield

The Historic Restaurant In New Jersey Where You Can Still Experience Colonial America

New Jersey’s history goes back a long way, even before there was a United States – and that includes its restaurants. The Garden State has more restaurants dating back before the founding of the United States than all but a few – and The Black Horse Tavern & Pub in Mendham dates back all the way to 1742. This colonial restaurant in New Jersey has updated its menu quite a bit over the year, but some things never change. It still has the same historic charm it did when it was a colonial tavern, but the rustic tavern has now expanded to include several dining rooms. You can indulge in the hearty meat-and-potatoes specialties of the old days, but the menu now includes modern favorites. The one thing that never changes is that when you’re dining at The Black Horse, you’re dining with history.

The facade of The Black Horse Tavern is bigger than it was in 1742, but it's still the same restaurant in a lot of ways.

Outside, keep an eye out for the historic marker explaining the long history of the tavern, coming up on three hundred years.

Inside, the central dining room still very much feels like it could have come right out of the colonial days.

The same goes for the traditional bar, where the skilled bartenders mix classic drinks that Founding Fathers may have sipped centuries ago.

The menu is a classic fusion of the old and the new, with the extensive appetizer menu offering a lot of Italian accents these days.

The Black Horse was always a popular place for hearty steaks, and the prime rib here is absolutely not to be missed.

But the rest of the entree menu has a lot of new flourishes, including some lighter touches like Poke.

Make sure to save room for a sweet finish, with classic desserts like cheesecake or the traditional Black Horse Celebration Cake.

Have you visited The Black Horse Tavern & Pub in Mendham? Let us know about your visit to this colonial restaurant in New Jersey in the comments section. To find out more, you can visit the official Black Horse Tavern website and Black Horse Tavern Facebook page of The Black Horse. If you’re excited to learn more about New Jersey’s early past, visit this tavern where George Washington drank ale.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Address: The Black Horse Tavern & Pub, 1 W Main St, Mendham Borough, NJ 07945, USA

The Historic Restaurant In New Jersey Where You Can Still Experience Colonial America

New Jersey In Your Inbox