Posted in Indiana Creepy May 04, 2023 by

These 6 Creepy Asylums In Indiana Will Chill You To The Bone

If you scare easily or do not enjoy learning about the many scary places in Indiana, we suggest turning around now. No, seriously. Just writing and researching this piece gave us the creeps! Ok, fine, if you decide to keep reading, just remember: we warned you. Below, you are going to learn more about six creepy abandoned asylums in Indiana that you’ll never forget (and neither will we – yikes.)

1. Logansport State Hospital
M.G. Callahan Co./Wikimedia
In 1883, there was just one asylum in Indianapolis, and it was full - so, they needed to build a new one. The new facility was built in 1884, and construction continued to expand the grounds for the next 70 years. The Old Longcliff Cemetery was nearby the hospital, and is still there somewhere - but it hasn't been locatable since 1891, when it became abandoned. Oops.
Logansport State Hospital, 1098 IN-25, Logansport, IN 46947, USA
2. Madison State Hospital
Squad546/AsylumProjects.org
In 1905, there was a bill passed to build a mental institution in southeast Indiana. When the first 600 patients were brought in by train, they were guarded by men with shotguns loaded with rock salt. The center focused on the humane treatment of patients with mental ailments and illnesses. There were many studies conducted at the hospital, including some on the brains of deceased patients. During the Great Depression, a shortage of funds meant that only 100 or so workers were left in charge of looking after more than 1,000 patients. People stayed longer than they needed to, and the types of therapy some people needed were not able to be administered. This, as well as the brain studies, gave the institution its nickname: Cragmont.
Madison State Hospital, 711 Green Rd, Madison, IN 47250, USA
3. Beatty Memorial Hospital
Mark Strozier/Flickr
The Beatty Memorial Hospital opened in 1951, and later opened a maximum-security division in 1954. This hospital replaced the "Hospital for Insane Criminals" at the Indiana State Prison (nobody said they were the best at naming things back then). Between the years of 1951 and 1979, there were over 18,000 patients admitted to the hospital. Some are said to have never left, even after it officially closed in 1991, becoming one of the many abandoned hospitals in Indiana.
Beatty Memorial Park, 209 5th Ave SE, Olympia, WA 98501, USA
4. The Brickmore Asylum
Mark Strozier/Flickr
Brickmore Asylum was opened in 1902, and it seemed like something straight out of your favorite horror movie. For instance, the warden cut costs by simply using patients to run the asylum. In addition to this, the asylum was known for its surprising number of deaths. The warden wouldn't allow visitors because he felt the patient's mental illnesses were "contagious". Rumors, and a supposed video, claimed that torture was used to "treat" some patients, including the use of an outlawed Tesla device.
5. The Indiana Hospital for Insane Criminals
Squad546/AsylumProject.org
There was a prison built in Michigan City in 1860, but in the 1900s, the state also realized they needed a place for the criminally insane. Opened in 1910, the Indiana Hospital for Insane Criminals was used to house 180 violent, ill, or otherwise unstable prisoners. It closed for good in 1945.
6. Richmond State Hospital
Squad546/AsylumProject.org
The land the Richmond State Hospital sits on was bought in 1878, and construction of the building didn't finish until 1890. The hospital has been called a lot of things over the years, including "East Indiana Hospital for the Insane". It has a lot of unique building features, including stained glass windows and cupolas. The building has been added onto, but the original architecture that remains is still very creepy.
Richmond State Hospital, 498 NW Eighteenth St, Richmond, IN 47374, USA

Hunger for more creepy tidbits of media from these spooky old-school Indiana institutions? Check this video out for some old footage from Brickmore:

The thing about creepy asylums in Indiana is that they tend to be abandoned, used as a “haunted” attraction, or remodeled/re-opened for use as something else. Take Norman Beatty Mental Hospital, for example, which was converted into the Westville Correctional Center in the late 1970s. We don’t know about you, but we wouldn’t want to go to a prison that used to be an old insane asylum!

The only question left to ask you is this – are you planning to visit any of these places, or do you just regret reading this article? Yikes!

Craving more creepy Indiana? Check this article out for a collection of all kinds of things!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

The OIYS Visitor Center

Creepy Asylums in Indiana

April 26, 2021
Tori Jane

Where are the most creepy places in Indiana? 

Indiana ghost stories are a staple of just about every generation, past and present, in the Hoosier State. Our state is filled to the brim with eerie, bizarre, and otherwise unsettling tales of hauntings, madmen, terrible crimes, frightening natural disasters, and more. Some of our favorite creepy places in Indiana are:

  • the infamous Hannah House, built in the late 1800s, where an unspeakably dark tragedy occurred and was subsequently covered up by the homeowners to avoid arrest for harboring escaping slaves along the Underground Railroad
  • Stepp Cemetery in Martinsville
  • Highland Lawn Cemetery, in Terre Haute

Are there many abandoned places in Indiana? 

Absolutely! The Hoosier state is an excellent place for the urban explorer, and there are plenty of abandoned places in Indiana to explore. Some of the most famous places in Indiana for abandoned buildings are:

  • Gary, where the abandoned post office is seriously too cool for words.
  • The ghost town of Corwin, which is said to be crawling with as many restless spirits as there are abandoned silos.
  • Kramer, Indiana, which has an abandoned hotel in the woods, overgrown and taken back by mother nature.

What are the scariest haunted places in Indiana?

There are some truly spooky haunted places in Indiana that you can visit. Some, however, seem to stick out above the rest in terms of sheer scariness. For example:

  • the Central State Hospital, in Indianapolis, which is an old insane asylum that’s well-known for its tortured souls that still lurk in the halls. It originally opened in 1848 and was known for its less-than-humane conditions, and it’s really no surprise that it’s so haunted now.
  • The Story Inn, in Nashville, which is said to be one of the most haunted places in the entire state, and better still, you can stay the night! It’s said to be haunted by the spirit of someone called The Blue Lady, who you’ll definitely have to meet for yourself someday.