Some places are simply timeless. Many of these spots seem to have found their groove long ago and stuck with it. After all, if it works, why change it? There’s one little sandwich shop in Indiana that checks all the boxes as a local classic hiding within Madison. It was established in 1933 – in the same exact place it’s at now – and over the decades, it’s needed to change very little. After all, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it – and Hinkle’s Sandwich Shop was never “broke” to begin with. Take a look at this culinary legend local to small-town Indiana:

Related Stories

You'd Never Know Some Of The Best Chicago-Style Eats In Indiana Are Hiding Deep In The Middle Of Nowhere

You'd Never Know Some Of The Best Chicago-Style Eats In Indiana Are Hiding Deep In The Middle Of Nowhere

One Of The Most Rustic Restaurants In Indiana Is Also One Of The Most Delicious

One Of The Most Rustic Restaurants In Indiana Is Also One Of The Most Delicious

The Chicken House Is A Hole-In-The-Wall Diner In Indiana With Some Of The Best Fried Chicken In Town

The Chicken House Is A Hole-In-The-Wall Diner In Indiana With Some Of The Best Fried Chicken In Town

If you’re interested in the full menu for this adorable little sandwich shop in Indiana, check out the official website, which is simple, sweet, and straight to the point. What kind of sandwiches are your favorites? Tell us about your picks in the comments!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Explore Indiana