Vintage pie shops are often a thing of the past. But what if we told you there was a small, charming, filled-with-flavor pie shop in Princeton, Illinois, that is worth driving across the state to visit? Walking into Myrtle’s Pie Shop in Illinois is like walking into a family home filled with sweet scents of pies cooking in the oven. Satisfy your dessert cravings with a trip to this most memorable spot.

There is a pie shop in the small town of Princeton, Illinois that has been serving up delicious homemade pies for many years.
Google Local/Pat C
Myrtle’s Pies in Illinois is a delightfully rustic pie shop that is as adorable as it is tasty.
Tripadvisor/tammy s
Just walking into Myrtle’s, you’ll be greeted by a delicious array of smells. Then, approaching the counter, you’ll see exactly why. Rows of fresh, homemade pies, just waiting to be devoured.
Tripadvisor/tammy s.

Related Stories

The Best Donuts In Illinois Are Served Up At This Incredible Small-Town Bakery

The Best Donuts In Illinois Are Served Up At This Incredible Small-Town Bakery

 Noir d'Ebene Chocolat et Patisserie Brings A Little Sweetness - And Touch Of Paris - To Illinois

Noir d'Ebene Chocolat et Patisserie Brings A Little Sweetness - And Touch Of Paris - To Illinois

 Beatrix Just Might Have The Most Epic Dessert Selection In All Of Illinois

Beatrix Just Might Have The Most Epic Dessert Selection In All Of Illinois
There is a pie option for everyone, whether it’s cream pies or fruit pies, seasonal pies, and much more. The selection of pies here is always varied and always spectacular.
Google Local/Ray Fizzle
For anyone who shows up with a big appetite, try as many of the pies as you can! You never know when a new favorite is waiting in the wings.
Tripadvisor/Tammy S
Even the traditional slices of pie taste better at Myrtle’s. A crisp, sweet apple paired with vanilla ice cream is pure perfection.
Google Local/Jeff
Also, if you want to bring the party home, you can! Myrtle’s offers a whole case of Take-And-Bake options to choose from.
Google Local/Keith Bloompott

Have you ever been to Myrtle’s Pie Shop in Illinois? What are your favorite pies from the shop? Share in the comments section! Or you can peruse all the flavors this shop offers by visiting Myrtle’s Pie Shop Facebook Page.

Not quite ready to satisfy your sweet tooth? Why not stop at Prime Quarter Steakhouse in Princeton, Illinois, for huge cuts of meat?

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Illinois

Featured Addresses
Myrtle's Pie, 927 N Main St, Princeton, IL 61356, USA