The Beloved Hole-in-the-Wall That Serves Arguably the Best Pizza in All of Ohio

Old Scratch Dayton in Ohio offers exceptional Neapolitan-style pizza in a casual, friendly setting.

Here in Ohio, we're pretty serious about our pizza. Whether you're looking for a deep-dish pizza, New York-style pizza, or something else altogether, you won't have to search long and hard to find excellent pie in the Buckeye State. Today's feature destination is one that has become a favorite among both locals and visitors alike, and it's no mystery why. Its unassuming exterior may remind you of a hole-in-the-wall, but what awaits you inside is positively exceptional. Here's more on what you can look forward to when you visit Old Scratch Dayton: some of the best pizza in Ohio.

We should be clear that Old Scratch isn't your typical hole-in-the-wall restaurant in Ohio. In fact, it's pretty hip. Yet driving by from the outside, you may not realize that some of the best pizza in Ohio awaits beyond this unassuming exterior.

Old Scratch Pizza specializes in Neapolitan-style pizzas that are cooked to perfection in an 800° wood-burning oven. This high heat allows for the most delicious crust, which is both crispy, light, and chewy all at once. You'll just have to try it for yourself!

The vibe at Old Scratch Pizza is casual, friendly, and very local. The restaurant is walk-in-only and counter service, meaning you won't have a traditional server but will order and pay ahead of taking a seat.

At any given time, there are about 10 delicious pizza varieties to choose from. Each is crafted using local ingredients whenever possible. From classic pepperoni to prosciutto with arugula, there's truly something for everyone.

In addition to pizza, you'll find an assortment of starters, salads, and desserts on the menu at this hole-in-the-wall restaurant in Ohio that will really round out your meal. Trust us when we say, just about everything on the list is worth sampling! There's also an impressive drink list for those looking for local beer or wine to pair with their food.

Have you ever dined at Old Scratch Dayton? Do you believe that this joint serves up some of the best pizza in Ohio? Be sure to share this article with someone you'd love to visit with! For more information, you can visit Old Scratch Dayton online, or check out Old Scratch Dayton on Facebook.

If you need a place to stay while you're exploring the area, check out this list of unique vacation rentals in Dayton, OH.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest updates and news

All Stories