This article has been retired and no longer being updated. For fresh travel inspiration, explore our homepage.
FoodRestaurants

This One Restaurant In Colorado Has Some Of The Most Amazing And Unique Pizza You’ve Ever Tried

All Star Pizzeria in Fountain, Colorado, offers a unique Pickle Ranch Pizza that stands out for its unusual toppings and local acclaim.

Published Apr 23, 2019

Written by 

Annie Sandmeier

Pickles... do you love 'em or hate 'em? I’m on Team Pickle and always ask for extra on burgers, sandwiches, and even pizza. You read the right, folks: you can order pickles atop a delicious pie at this Colorado restaurant that serves one of the most amazing and unique pizzas you’ll ever try.

The iconic All Star Pizzeria is located in the town of Fountain and is billed as the "Best Local Pizza in Colorado."

alt
Google/Detu Maki

Just one bite of an All Star pie and you will agree with their slogan!

alt
Allstar Pizzeria Facebook

Family owned and operated, All Star's has become a community staple thanks to not only its pies, but also its down-home feel and friendly staff.

alt
Google/Wayne Klein

Like most pizza joints, All Star serves a number of popular options including pepperoni, supreme, and meat lovers, but one, in particular, stands out from the crowd in terms of taste: the one-of-a-kind Pickle Ranch Pizza!

alt
Google/Ashley White

Your eyes do not deceive you; that is indeed pickles, beef, bacon, ranch, and onions atop the delicious homemade dough.

Not a fan of pickles? No worries, as All Star serves a number of more traditional pies...

alt
Google / Steven Taylor

...calzones and sandwiches...

alt
Mickey Pinegar / Google

...and tasty sides.

alt
Google / Steven Taylor

All Star Pizzeria is located at 729 Dale St. in Fountain and is open Sunday through Thursday from 10:30 a.m. to 9 p.m., and Fridays & Saturdays from 10:30 a.m. to 10 p.m.

alt
Ereck Stephens / Google

For more information, please visit All Star's website.

alt
Google Maps

Check out other stellar pies by clicking 10 Colorado Pizza Parlors Sure to Give You Your Fix.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest updates and news

All Stories

Nature

Skip the Hikes and Try This Kansas Rail Trail Instead

There’s no need to hike when you can wheel or wander along this scenic Kansas rail trail.

by Stephanie Frias
on Jun 6
A meandering, gravel trail passing through green pastures with yellow blooms beneath a brilliant, blue sky. It's the Prairie Sunset Trail, a rail trail in Kansas.
Stays
Vacation Rentals

7 Waterfront Hawai’i Rentals So Stunning They Don’t Feel Real

From rainforest cabins with private waterfall pools to cliffside oceanfront homes and sandy beachfront condos, these waterfront rentals offer immersive island escapes where the sound of water, whether river, rain, or ocean, is always part of the experience.

by Kate Orlando
on Jun 6
Looking up at a waterfront Airbnb in Hawaii that overlooks a small waterfall.
Experiences
Attractions

The Hidden Attraction in New Jersey That People Still Seek Out to This Day

Hidden in plain sight, this remarkable New Jersey destination continues to spark curiosity to this day.

by Kim Falchek
on Jun 6
Birds sit on the remains of the sunken Atlantus shipwreck which sits in the waters off Sunset Beach in Cape May, New Jersey.
Trips & Routes
Cities

This Walkable Coastal City in Maine Is a Must-Visit Gem

This stunning Maine city is easy to explore on foot, with scenic views, local shops, and must-see attractions all within walking distance.

by Megan Todaro
on Jun 6
An aerial view of Downloaded the harbor and town of Rockland, Maine. Boats line the harbor and the streets are walkable in every direction.
Nature

This Arizona State Park Has a Charming Town Right Next Door — and Nobody Talks About It

Discover a charming small town near Kartchner Caverns State Park that’s perfect for your next getaway, with great stays and easy park access.

by Melanie Johnson
on Jun 6
A woman sitting on a bench overlooking the mountains in Benson, a small town near Kartchner Caverns in AZ.