Flagler Beach Has Coquina Sand That Reveals Fossilized Shark Teeth After Every Storm

Florida may be best known for its theme parks and notable beach towns, but situated along its Atlantic Coast lies a treasure hunter’s paradise that often flies under the radar. When you think of treasure, you're probably thinking of a sunken ship out in the shimmering turquoise waters of the Caribbean. At least that's where my mind goes. But what if I told you there was a different kind of treasure waiting for you in Florida?

For those willing to explore the Atlantic side of the state, Flagler Beach offers a windswept, rust-hued stretch of coastline that’s a dream for fossil hunters, shark tooth seekers, and shell collectors. Located between St. Augustine and Daytona Beach, this laid-back town and its shoreline serve as one of Florida’s most underrated destinations for discovery.

Unlike the soft, white sands of the Gulf, Flagler’s beaches have a unique coquina sand, orange-tinted and speckled with bits of crushed shells, that helps fossils and teeth stand out. After a strong tide or storm, it’s not uncommon to find fossilized shark teeth from long-extinct species, as well as the occasional prehistoric bone fragment or ancient marine shell. Whether you bring a sifter or simply scan the tide line with your eyes, there’s a thrill in never knowing what the ocean might deliver next.

Part of the charm here is the untouched feel of it all. There are no towering condos or big-box resorts here, just swaying sea oats, a historic fishing pier, and friendly locals who might share a tip or two about where to look. Mornings are especially ideal for combing the shore, when the crowds are light, and the finds are fresh. It's always nice to be one of the first people out on the sand, seeing what the tide brought in overnight, and helming your very own natural discovery.

Early morning after a storm or high tide is prime time for finding these coastal treasures, and you’ll want to scan both the wrack line (where sea debris settles) and areas just beneath the surface of wet sand. For the best experience, bring a small mesh bag, a scoop, and plenty of patience.

Flagler Beach may not be as famous for shark tooth hunting as Venice or Manasota Key, but this quiet stretch of Atlantic coastline offers its own surprising bounty, especially after strong tides or storms. Fossilized shark teeth, often black or dark brown from thousands or even millions of years of mineralization, can be found nestled among bits of broken shells. Teeth from extinct species like the megalodon or more common finds like lemon and bull sharks sometimes wash ashore, especially at low tide or following a storm surge.

Do you have any fun stories of Flagler Beach and Florida treasures being found? If you haven't found anything at this iconic St. Augustine beach, maybe you have uncovered other treasures at beaches on Florida's other coast. Also, if you want a different type of treasure hunt in Florida altogether, you'll be pleasantly surprised at what you'll find at St. George Island.