We all love a good supper club. In fact, we collected a list of our favorite small town supper clubs you probably hadn’t visited, and you responded by sharing even more delectable hidden gems. Inspired by your suggestions, here are 12 more underrated small town supper clubs in Wisconsin worth visiting.

1. Black Otter Supper Club - Hortonville
TripAdvisor/HeatherK
TripAdvisor/JenPhotoGal
No, your eyes don't deceive you. That's a 72 oz. cut of steak right. Indulge in giant, scrumptious meals at Block Otter Supper Club. This family-owned restaurant has delighted diners since 1972. You'll find them at 503 S Nash St, Hortonville, WI 54944. To learn more, visit their website here.
2. Lake Aire Supper Club - Clintonville
Facebook/LakeAireSupperClub
TripAdvisor/PaulK
The steaks are amazing, but folks really like the perch and haddock here, as well. Lake Aire Supper Club is located at County Hwy Y, Clintonville, WI 54929. To learn more, visit their Facebook page here.
3. The Nutshell - Antigo
Facebook/MillersNutshell
TripAdvisor/SpecialLuckyKT
Only open on Fridays and Saturdays, this place is small, but packed with all the things that make a Wisconsin supper club great. You'll find The Nutshell at N696 County Rd S, Antigo, WI 54409. To learn more, visit their Facebook page here.
4. Connell's Supper Club - Chippewa Falls
TripAdvisor/AMBVRN
TripAdvisor/MatthewC
These folks have famous onion rings, so make sure you add an order to your table. This amazing Wisconsin supper club is located at 18525 50th Ave, Chippewa Falls, WI 54729. To learn more, visit their website here.
5. Pine Tree Supper Club - New London
TripAdvisor/NLWI
Facebook/PineTreeSupperClub
Serving folks for more than 50 years, Pine Tree Supper Club is a local favorite for their fish, seafood and steaks. You'll find them at E8095 WI-54, New London, WI 54961. To learn more, visit their Facebook page here.
6. Old Towne Inn - Westby
Priceline
TripAdvisor/LMFfarmer
Known for its prime rib and salad bar, Old Towne Inn is a must-visit small town supper club in Wisconsin. It's located at 100 E Old Town Rd, Westby, WI 54667. To learn more, visit their website here.

Related Stories

With Its Own Private Playground, This Incredible Cafe In Wisconsin Is Perfect For Families

With Its Own Private Playground, This Incredible Cafe In Wisconsin Is Perfect For Families

 This Speakeasy Hidden In An Old Harness Shop In Wisconsin Is Perfect For A Date Night

This Speakeasy Hidden In An Old Harness Shop In Wisconsin Is Perfect For A Date Night

 I Toured A Cheese Museum In Wisconsin Because Of Course I Did

I Toured A Cheese Museum In Wisconsin Because Of Course I Did
7. White Stag Inn - Rhinelander
TripAdvisor/Amy R
TripAdvisor/LaCrosseIndians
At White Stag Inn, you can watch chefs cook your steak in the open flame oven right in the middle of the room! If that doesn't whet your appetite, nothing will. You'll find this unique restaurant at 7141 State Rd 17, Rhinelander, WI 54501. To learn more, visit their Facebook page here.
8. Haase's Supper Club - Winneconne
Facebook/Haase's Supper Club
Facebook/HaasesSupperClub
Steaks bigger than your face and really delicious sides bring folks back to Haase's. They are located at 9497 County Hwy D, Winneconne, WI 54986. To learn more, visit their Facebook page here.
9. Red's Supper Club - Cuba City
TripAdvisor
TripAdvisor/Aaron B
Red's Supper Club has a great fish fry, and there's a beautiful, scenic drive to get there! What could be better? You'll find them at 27569 WI-81, Cuba City, WI 53807. To learn more, visit their website here.
10. Moose Inn Supper Club - Wautoma
Facebook/Moose Inn
TripAdvisor/KathyH
Make sure you check out Moose Inn Supper Club's fantastic coconut shrimp, and don't forget to enjoy a refreshing ice cream drink for dessert. They are located at W6846 WI-21, Wautoma, WI 54982. To learn more, visit their website here.
11. McGregor's Blink Bonnie Supper Club - St. Germain
TripAdvisor/IlkaP
TripAdvisor/Seament44
This spot is a pillar of the Northwoods. It's rustic and charming and downright delicious. You'll find McGregor's Blink Bonnie Supper Club at 8997 WI-70, St Germain, WI 54558. To learn more, visit their Facebook page here.
12. Schwarz's Supper Club - New Holstein
TripAdvisor/Love2TrvlMM
TripAdvisor/Love2TrvlMM
Located in an old one-room tavern that's been remodeled several times, this quaint and charming supper club has plenty of delicious options. Schwarz's Supper Club can be found at W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061. To learn more, visit their website here.

What are your favorite underrated restaurants in Wisconsin? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below! And if you know another exceptional eatery we should feature, nominate it through our online form here.

Still hungry? Eat your way through the Wisconsin pizza bucket list for some truly incredible meals.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

small town supper clubs in Wisconsin

Elisa Regulski | May 21, 2020

What are the best underrated restaurants in Wisconsin?

Sometimes, the most delicious restaurants aren’t the most obvious. If you’re looking for some of the best underrated restaurants in Wisconsin, check out our list of often overlooked restaurants. Each establishment on this list serves mouthwatering meals that will blow you away.

What are the best supper clubs in Wisconsin?

There’s no doubt about it -- we love giant steaks and delicious cocktails here in the Dairy State. Black Otter Supper Club, located in Hortonville, is often praised as one of the most delicious restaurants around. You’ll also find wonderful meals at Ishnala Supper Club inside Mirror Lake State Park. If you’re still hungry, check out our list of the best supper clubs in Wisconsin.

What defines a Wisconsin supper club?

Out of towners may not know what a real Wisconsin supper club is. While each place offers its own unique menu, these restaurants do have something in common. In general, supper clubs are independently-owned restaurants that are only open for dinnertime. Their menus are often very limited, and they usually feature steak dishes and classic cocktails. Additionally, many supper clubs are located in rural locations.

Related Articles

Featured Addresses
503 S Nash St, Hortonville, WI 54944, USA
County Hwy Y, Clintonville, WI, USA
N696 County Rd S, Antigo, WI 54409, USA
18525 50th Ave, Chippewa Falls, WI 54729, USA
E8095 WI-54, New London, WI 54961, USA
100 E Old Town Rd, Westby, WI 54667, USA
7141 State Rd 17, Rhinelander, WI 54501, USA
9497 County Hwy D, Winneconne, WI 54986, USA
27569 WI-81, Cuba City, WI 53807, USA
W6846 WI-21, Wautoma, WI 54982, USA
8997 WI-70, St Germain, WI 54558, USA
W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061, USA