Pineapple on pizza might just be one of the most highly-contested food combinations in modern history (classic dish, or culinary crime?)...and the arguments can get pretty fierce on both sides. But whatever your stance on this sweet and savory combo (taste, much like beauty, is truly in the eye of the beholder, after all), there's no denying the appeal of quirky, unexpected flavor combos. And more often than not, those wacky foods are positively delicious when given a chance! Wyoming is no stranger to odd dishes, and we're certainly home to a number of restaurants that like to get their creative cuisine on. Tucked away in Gillette is one such culinary delight. For some of the craziest pizza in Wyoming, this delicious hidden gem doesn't just wow with its perfect wood-fired crusts; it's also home to some of the most unique pizzas we've ever seen. And we're all for it!

At first glance, Pizza Carrello doesn't seem like it would be harboring any exotic surprises. From the rustic, mountain lodge-inspired wood beams to the cozy pizza joint-esque interior, you would be right to assume fantastic handmade pies and great service. But there's so much more to love here.

A long-time favorite restaurant in Gillette, the classic Italian pizza at Pizza Carrello is more like a blank canvas. And a good work of art always starts with a quality foundation.

Here, every pie starts off with a homemade artisan crust and fresh, seasonal ingredients. Even hand-made cheeses! And every completed work of art gets baked to perfection in Pizza Carrello's own wood-fired oven for a delightful bite and ultimate flavor.

So what are those flavors exactly? Well, that depends on when you visit! But they're definitely out of the box.

From the unexpected to the decadent to the downright wacky, Pizza Carrello's regularly changing menu highlights the best ingredients of the season and showcases wonderfully unique pies, slices, and calzones. You never know what you'll find here!

Dill-lovers, rejoice! The Pickle Pizza at Pizza Carrello has you covered.

Fans swoon over their Dazzle Berry Pizza: a sweet and spicy combination of garlic-infused olive oil, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, ham, arugula, and jalapeño, taken to the next level with a sweet raspberry sauce.

Dazzled by the Dazzle Berry? Then the Steak and Strawberry pizza might be right up your alley too!

This summer-inspired pie features spicy BBQ sauce, slow-roasted brisket, and a vibrant strawberry slaw. It's appropriately nicknamed the Hootenanny Hoedown.

The Fruity Goat (which features goat cheese and blueberries) and the Vineyard & the Farm (which features grapes, house-made ricotta, prosciutto, and a delightful balsamic drizzle) both highlight the unique sweet and savory combinations that Pizza Carrello has come to be known for.

But past seasonal creations also include the epic Wurst (bratwurst, sauerkraut, and mustard sauce with Fontina and Mozzarella cheeses)...

Pair it with a German tap beer for an epic weekend celebration.

...the much-loved and delightfully peachy Devil Went Down to Parma...

...and the cozy brunch special Maple Staple, complete with blueberries, house-made ricotta, oranges, almonds, fresh maple syrup, and a powdered sugar-dusted crust.

We haven't mentioned the brunches yet, though, have we? These weekend treats are a MUST! Dutch baby pancakes, cage-free egg frittatas, house-roasted coffee, wood-fired French toast, fresh-squeezed orange juice… there's no better (or more delicious) way to start your day!

Of course, traditional pizza lovers can still get their fix here, with no classic topping skipped over. Mushrooms, pepperoni, Buffalo chicken, bacon - all the classics are available.

And yes, even pineapple!

With a few special menu items ready and waiting to delight. The Firecracker and Fajita pizzas are downright exploding with flavor!

But whether you go traditional or wild for your main course, don't forget to finish your meal off with a sweet, tempting dessert pizza, tiramisu, or a delightful dessert calzone.

Hungry yet?

Intrigued? This is just a small sampling of what Pizza Carrello has to offer! Breakfast pizzas, dinner pizzas, dessert pizzas…plus daily fresh-baked breads! You'll find everything here! For those who are totally over the classic pepperoni slice (or maybe a classic slice is exactly what you're looking for), we think this local gem is an absolute must-visit in every season.

Stay on top of hours, ever-changing menu additions, and special events on the Pizza Carrello website or Facebook page.

After you've had your fill of pizza, take in some Wild West beauty! These road trips and scenic byways in Wyoming are the best way to dive into all of the sights, eats, and delights that the Cowboy State has to offer.