One of the very best parts of this time of year is the availability of all kinds of squashes and gourds, but especially pumpkin. Folks wait all year for this delicious treat. There’s just something very familiar and cozy about pumpkin pie. It’s nostalgic and welcoming and makes us think of family gatherings and big, comfortable sweaters. Here in Wisconsin, we have some of the best bakeries in the country, so it’s no surprise that you can also find some of the best pumpkin pies, as well. These 10 bakeries serve up this wonderful fall concoction, so time to head out to taste test and decide who makes your favorite.

1. Not By Bread Alone - Green Bay
Not By Bread Alone, 940 Hansen Rd, Green Bay, WI 54304, USA
Facebook/Notbybreadalone
All year round, Not By Bread Alone in Green Bay is known for stuffed sausage bread, and for some reason, that made me think they'd be great at the comforting deliciousness of pumpkin pie. I was not wrong. It's a wonderful crust and a great consistency. Located at 940 Hansen Rd., Green Bay, WI 54304.
2. Norske Nook - Osseo, Rice Lake, Hayward and DeForest
Norske Nook - Osseo, 13804 W 7th St, Osseo, WI 54758, USA
Facebook/Norske.Nook
For many, this is the pie by which they judge all other pies. Norske Nook is literally the pies your grandma used to make because their kitchen is full of Omas still making these delicious treats. Located at 13804 7th St., Osseo, WI 54758, 2900 Pioneer Ave., Rice Lake, WI 54868, and Corner of Main and Holum, DeForest, WI 53532.
3. Blue Willow Cafe - Wausau
Blue Willow Cafe, 1111 N 4th Ave, Wausau, WI 54401, USA
Facebook/BlueWillowCafe
This diner is a local favorite for home-cooked comfort food. Make sure to save room for dessert, since the pastry case is chock full of enough choices to satisfy the whole family. The pumpkin here is rich and decadent - don't forget the whipped cream! Located at 1111 N 4th Ave., Wausau, WI 54401.
4. Door County Bakery - Sister Bay
Door County Bakery, LLC, 10048 WI-57, Sister Bay, WI 54234, USA
Facebook/DoorCountyBakery
When you've got abundant fresh produce around to create some of the best fillings around, you perfect an amazing pie. These folks have the experience and know-how and make some of the best pies in the state. Located at 10048 WI-57, Sister Bay, WI 54234.
5. Batch Bakehouse - Madison
Batch Bakehouse, 1402 Williamson St, Madison, WI 53703, USA
Facebook/BatchBakehouse
Batch Bakehouse wins for the prettiest pumpkin pie, but it's not all window dressing. It's a nice thick crust to stand up to the substantial filling. Flaky and buttery and cooked to perfection. Located at 1402 Williamson St., Madison, WI 53703.
6. Linda's Bakery - West Salem
Linda's Bakery, 190 East City, WI-16, West Salem, WI 54669, USA
Facebook/LindasBakery
For more than four decades, Linda's Bakery has been serving this community and is one of the best bakeries around. Order your pie a day ahead of time and a fresh-baked delight will be waiting for you! Located at 190 East City, WI-16, West Salem, WI 54669.
7. Manderfield's Home Bakery - Appleton and Menasha
Manderfield's Home Bakery, 5100 W Michaels Dr, Appleton, WI 54913, USA
Facebook/Manderfields
Three generations of this family have been baking for more than 70 years. The gold standard in the Fox Valley, Manderfield's makes a delightful pumpkin pie that's both perfectly packed with flavor but still a little fluffy. Located at 5100 W. Michaels Dr., Appleton, WI 54913, W3176 Springfield Dr., Appleton, WI 54915 and 811 Plank Rd., Menasha, WI 54952.
8. Elsie Mae's Canning & Pies - Milwaukee
Elsie Mae's Canning and Pies, 1101 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, USA
Elsie Mae's Canning & Pies/Facebook
There’s nothing better than grandma’s recipes and locally sourced ingredients. That’s the winning combination of this unique pie shop that specializes in canning and baking sweet treats. The pumpkin pie is festive and oh so delicious. Located at 1101 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202.
9. Uncle Mike's Bake Shoppe - Suamico, Green Bay and DePere
Uncle Mike's Bake Shoppe, 1840 Dickinson Rd, De Pere, WI 54115, USA
Facebook/UncleMike'sBakeShoppe
It's impossible to walk out of this place without a bag full of food, so come for that delicious pumpkin pie, but know you'll probably leave with a kringle, some bread, and more. This bake shop is amazing with flavors and the pie is perfection. Located at 1840 Dickinson Rd., De Pere, WI 54115, 2514 Lineville Rd., Suamico, WI 54313 and 2999 East Mason St., Green Bay, WI 54311.
10. Crystal Cafe - Iola
Crystal Cafe, 126 N Main St, Iola, WI 54945, USA
Facebook/CrystalCafeIola
One of my absolute favorite small-town Wisconsin spots, this place has a wonderful backstory about a mom trying to provide for her children. Now the kids run the place but mom's famous pie is what people come back for. Located at 126 N Main St., Iola, WI 54945.

Which restaurant or bakery in Wisconsin makes your favorite pumpkin pie? Or what are some of your favorite pies that you prefer to eat? Let us know in the comments!

Looking for more sweet stuff? Check out these amazing bakeries you won’t be able to wait to try.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

More to Explore

Best Pumpkin Pies In Wisconsin

Melanie J. | August 26, 2022

What are some other pie shops in Wisconsin?

When it comes to pie shops and bakeries, we have no shortage of them in Wisconsin. But it’s hard to choose one that stands out amongst the rest. There are pie shops like Elsie Mae's Canning and Pies that offer both sweet and savory pies as well as jams. All their ingredients are locally sourced from nearby farms. It’s no wonder that Elsie’s made the list of top 40 pie shops in America. Another pie shop that is equally impressive is Sweetie Pie located in Fish Creek. With traditional methods and simple ingredients, you’ll be eating some of the best pies you’ve ever had in your life. We recommend trying the delicious sweet and tart cherry pie, it’s a crowd favorite. Other notable pie shops include Stockholm Pie and General Store, Honeypie Cafe, Mr. Dye's Pies, and Lake Geneva Pie Company. Lastly, though it’s not a pie shop, Elegant Farmer is a grocery store located in Mukwonago, with an amazing bakery. Do try the famous apple pie, it’s to die for. And here is a list of more pie shops in Wisconsin.    

Besides pumpkin pies, what are some other popular pastries in Wisconsin?

We love eating scrumptious baked goods in Wisconsin. Those sweet treats are always a delight, don’t you agree? Though we love everything in a pastry case like pies, muffins, cookies, and more, there is one pastry that we can’t get enough of. And that yummy goodness is Kringle. A Danish tradition from the 1800s, this flaky buttery treat filled with fruits or nuts and topped with icing is the official pastry of our state. And one of the best places to try this staple is O&H Danish Bakery. There are a few locations including Oak Creek, Sturtevant, Mt Pleasant, and Racine, where you can purchase this treat. Other favorite pastries include cream puffs, gingerbread muffins, pumpkin cookies, and more. And here’s an article listing some other Wisconsin sweet treats that we love to eat. 

Related Articles

Explore Wisconsin