The tiny town of Gillett is about 40 miles northwest of Green Bay and 80 miles due east of Wausau. It might be closer to the UP than it is anything else, but it’s well worth your time to detour toward this little hamlet as it’s home to some of the very best desserts you’ve ever imagined. If you love a hometown diner where everyone seems to know everyone else, everything is handmade right on site and is so inexpensive you won’t believe your eyes when you get the bill, you’ll want to head straight to OJ’s Midtown in Wisconsin.

Tucked into the small town of Gillett, OJ's is a small diner spot that serves up spectacular home-cooked, filling food.
Facebook/OJsMidtown
From stellar soups to giant burgers, OJ's Midtown has it all. You won't regret heading here for a meal.
But let's be honest, what you've really come here for is the dessert. These folks serve up 20 different pies on a regular basis and usually have at least two pies featured each month.
Facebook/OJsMidtown
This is the list of flavors they served up on Pi Day recently. But, really, a list this long isn't saved for special days around here.
Facebook/OJsMidtown
OJ's has been around for more than 40 years and there are multiple generations of this family making amazing pies and other desserts right here in the kitchen.
Facebook/OJsMidtown
Though the pies tend to get the bulk of the attention, you'll also find amazing large apple dumplings, cakes, cheesecakes and something they call schnibbles - cookies made with leftover pie crust dough that have a bunch of butter and sugar and deliciousness packed into every bite.
This place is cozy and welcoming and it feels a bit like it's been here forever. You'll find regulars and visitors alike, as well as folks who've trekked just to taste the wonderful after-dinner treats.
TripAdvisor/MaganE

Related Stories

15 Best Places To Get Wisconsin's Iconic Frozen Custard

15 Best Places To Get Wisconsin's Iconic Frozen Custard

 Treat Yourself To A Slew Of Sweets With A Visit To This Country Bakery In Wisconsin

Treat Yourself To A Slew Of Sweets With A Visit To This Country Bakery In Wisconsin

 This Wisconsin Diner Is Famous For Pie...In All Its Forms  

This Wisconsin Diner Is Famous For Pie...In All Its Forms  
You couldn't possibly grow tired of pie at this shop and they make a ton of flavors you've never even dreamed up.
Facebook/OJsMidtown
During the holiday season, try the mint creme pie that has a layer of chocolate on the bottom. The cream pies and meringues look light and fluffy and like they could reach up to the sky.
Just like the cream pies, the cheesecakes here are silky smooth and chock full of flavor. The bakers at OJ's Midtown in Wisconsin make all kinds of amazing flavor combinations.
Facebook/OJsMidtown
We don't know how anyone comes in here for anything other than dessert. Who can think of fish fries when there's a table full of drool-worthy sweet treats just waiting for you to explore it?
Facebook/OJsMidtown
There's just no denying that a trip to OJ's is totally doable from a bunch of Wisconsin cities and it's so, so worth it to be able to experience the transcendent joy of dessert here.
Facebook/OJsMidtown
Come hungry and bring a cooler so you can take additional treats home with you. OJ's makes the very best desserts in Wisconsin.
Facebook/OJsMidtown
OJ's Midtown is located at 128 W Main St., Gillett, WI 54124. For more mouthwatering pictures and an up-to-the-minute accounting of what sweet treats they're baking up today, check out the official Facebook page for OJ's Midtown in Wisconsin.

Have you been to OJ’s Midtown in Wisconsin? What is your favorite sweet treat? Which pie do you dream about? Let us know in the comments! And if you know another place to get mouthwatering desserts in Wisconsin, nominate it for a chance to be featured.

Do you love dessert? We created an amazing Wisconsin dessert road trip that lets you gorge on yummy pies, cakes, ice cream and more!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

OJ's Midtown in Wisconsin

Elisa Regulski | August 17, 2020

What are the best hidden gem restaurants in Wisconsin?

We always love discovering new hidden gem restaurants in Wisconsin! If you need to shake up your dining routine, visit Suncrest Gardens Pizza Farm. Everything served here is made with only fresh and delicious ingredients. Come by and enjoy a scrumptious slice in the breezy, open air. The food and atmosphere will totally blow you away. For more wonderful pizza, visit Rustique in Suamico. This hidden gem restaurant is worth going out of your way for. Nestled inside an old church, this eatery is both gorgeous and inviting. Be sure to order their pesto fries! You’ll never want to stop munching on these tasty treats.

Where can I find the best dessert in Wisconsin?

Sweet tooth acting up again? There are so many fantastic places to get dessert in Wisconsin. For some wonderful treats, visit Amy’s Candy Kitchen in Cedarburg. From the gorgeous caramel apples to the wonderful toffees, this little shop does it all. If you loved this place, you should also check out Sweet Memories Candy Shoppe in Lakewood. The whimsical atmosphere will whisk you back to the sweet days of your childhood. Fill your bags with bulk chocolates and hard candies. It’s a little slice of happiness!

What are the best diners in Wisconsin?

If you’re looking for one of the best diners in Wisconsin, we know just where you should go: Delta Diner. This cozy eatery serves mouthwatering comfort food meals that will remind you of home. You’ll love the retro decor and friendly servers. For more scrumptious meals, visit Clinton Kitchen. You’ll love their classic crinkle-cut fries and magnificent burgers. Picadilly Lilly Airport Diner, located in Spring Green, is also known for whipping up a tasty meal. No matter what you order, you won’t be disappointed.

Related Articles

Explore Wisconsin

Featured Addresses
128 E Main St, Gillett, WI 54124, USA