For many locals and visitors to Charleston alike, the local historic graveyards are a source of mystery and intrigue. And sometimes, even visiting one of them during the daylight hours can be a bit unnerving. While many of the graveyards in the Holy City are well groomed (like Charleston’s Magnolia Cemetery) there’s one very old graveyard that’s not so well maintained as the others – although it is maintained.

You may be a bit surprised when you first set foot in the cemetery at the Unitarian Church, found a bit off the usual beaten path and on Archdale Street in downtown Charleston.
Google Local/Rich Burdett
The graveyard gained its first official resident just a few short years after the end of the Revolutionary War. The church was dedicated in 1787 after the construction was halted during the war and repairs were made following the war.
The overgrown nature of this more than 200-year-old cemetery in the heart of the historic district is something you can get over as you explore this charming old graveyard. But it's not as easy to get over the ghosts that are said to haunt this locale.
Google Local/Conner Holt
At least three souls are rumored to haunt this space — and the suspected identities of two of them will likely surprise you.
Perhaps the most famous of the trio is the young woman said to be the inspiration for Edgar Allan Poe's last finished poem, "Annabel Lee."
Google Local/Rick VanderPol
It's widely known that Poe was stationed in on Sullivans Island in the early 1800s during his enlistment in the service.
As the story goes: he met a much younger girl, named Anna, and the two were immediately in love. Some versions of this story say the two would secretly meet in the Unitarian Church cemetery.
Google Local/Andrew Dols
They were forced to meet in secret because Anna was from a high-brow family in Charleston and the patriarch did not approve of his daughter's involvement with a service man.

Before long, Poe (who was enlisted under the name Edgar A. Perry) was reassigned to a new post far, far away. Some believe Anna's wealthy father pulled strings to send him away.
Soon after, Anna became ill and died. Her father bought six side-by-side burial plots in the Unitarian Church cemetery and dug them all up, placing Anna's body in one of them in an unmarked grave. Why?
Google Local/DrCowinabox
It's said he did it out of spite so that Edgar (who DID return for his Anna) wouldn't be able to grieve for her at her grave. Today, visitors who see or sense Anna's ghost in the cemetery get a sense that she's looking for Edgar.
Another ghost said to haunt the cemetery is Lavina Fisher.
Flickr/Spencer Means
Although America's reported first female serial killer, who resided in Charleston at the time of her arrest and hanging, isn't known to be buried at the Unitarian Church cemetery, some visitors have reported seeing her ghost dressed in a white gown roaming the graveyard.
Although some people believe "Annabel Lee" was written about Poe's wife, many Charlestonians believe the real muse for Poe's last finished poem was Anna Ravenel.
Google Local/Conner Holt
What do you believe? And have you visited the creepy graveyard at this church and felt anything unusual during your time there? We'd love to know the answer to both so join the discussion in the comments!

Want to explore even more creepy graveyards in South Carolina? Check out five hikes that lead to abandoned graveyards in the woods, and one of the most haunted cemeteries in the state where it’s believe the apparition of a witch roams the space after dark.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Related Articles

Explore South Carolina

Featured Addresses
4 Archdale St, Charleston, SC 29401, USA