Posted in Pennsylvania Dining May 01, 2022 by

7 Pennsylvania Amish Country Restaurants With Food So Good You’ll Be Back For Seconds

Sit down for a relaxing homemade meal with friends and family at one of the authentic Amish restaurants in Pennsylvania. Opt for a delicious buffet-style meal or order a platter with hearty portions. These 7 best Amish restaurants in Pennsylvania promise a unique and delicious dining experience.

1. Katie's Kitchen – 200 Hartman Bridge Road, Strasburg, PA 17579
Yelp/J.M.
Yelp/Bex L.
Make sure you go to Katie's Kitchen hungry because you'll have plenty of home cooked Amish meals - meatloaf and home style chicken, for example - from which to choose from the breakfast, lunch, and dinner menus. Save room for an authentic, homemade Amish dessert, such as apple dumplings and homemade pie. If you're looking for an Amish food restaurant, you've come to the right place.
2. Dutch Eating Place – 1136 Arch Street, Philadelphia, PA 19107
Yelp/Tammy L.
Yelp/Patty M.
Next time you're in Reading Market Terminal in Philadelphia, stop by the Dutch Eating Place. Serving homemade breakfast and lunch, the charming food counter features such homemade dishes as chicken corn soup, real mashed potatoes with gravy, and hot roast beef. If you can't find any "Mennonite restaurants near me," you've found the next best thing - a beloved Amish restaurant.
3. Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant – 2760 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird In Hand, PA 17505
Yelp/Karen C.
Yelp/Mary Y.
Go to Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant hungry because you can order from either the traditional menu or indulge in the all-you-can eat Pennsylvania Dutch smorgasboard, featuring fresh fruits and vegetables from nearby Amish farms. At this Amish restaurant, you can choose from such dishes as chicken pot pie, Lancaster County baked ham, and roast turkey. Bird-in-Hand serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
4. Hometown Kitchen – 18 Furance Road, Quarryville, PA 17566
Facebook/Hometown Kitchen
Facebook/Hometown Kitchen
Hometown Kitchen, an authentic Amish restaurant with Amish cooks and servers, serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner daily. Choose from such dishes as barbecued meatballs, fried pickles, and potato salad. Hometown Kitchen features daily specials, such as the Friday Amish Wedding Meal, which includes homemade bread filling, chicken, mashed potatoes, and pepper slaw.
5. Dienner's Country Kitchen – 2855 Lincoln Hwy East, Ronks, PA 17572
Yelp/Pitbull D.
Yelp/Melissa N.
Eat as much - or as little - as your appetite allows at Dienner's Country Restaurant, which welcomes guests for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Guests can opt for the buffet or a platter. Specializing in authentic Pennsylvania Dutch food and one of the best Amish restaurants in Pennsylvania, Dienner's Country Restaurant serves a wide range of dishes, including rotisserie chicken, buttered noodles, and mashed potatoes.
6. 1899 Olde Mill Restaurant – 9 Queen Road, Intercourse, PA 17534
Yelp/Katie M.
Yelp/Brian F.
If you've been searching Google for a "Mennonite restaurant near me," you've found it! The 1899 Olde Mill Restaurant welcomes guests to enjoy homemade Amish, Mennonite, or American fare for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Choose from such varied menu items as homemade meatloaf, old-fashioned chicken and waffles, or homemade crab cakes, with a side of scrumptious homemade bread. To learn more, visit the official website for 1899 Olde Mill Restaurant.
7. Good 'N Plenty Restaurant – 150 Eastbrook Road, Smoketown, PA 17576
Yelp/Joy G.
Yelp/Daniel Z.
Editor's Note: Good 'N Plenty Restaurant is permanently closed. In the heart of Lancaster sits Good 'N Plenty Restaurant, serving authentic Amish food for lunch and dinner. Opt for the family style dining or order individual meals from the menu, which features such dishes as meat loaf, fried chicken, and roast beef. Stop by the bakery for freshly made desserts and bread.

Have you been to any of these restaurants in Amish Country? What are your favorite places to get comfort food in Pennsylvania? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below. And if you know another must-visit eatery, nominate it for a chance to be featured.

Dine at one of the 8 best Amish restaurants in Pennsylvania for a home cooked meal or try one of the best hometown restaurants that will take you back in time.

Address: 150 Eastbrook Road, Smoketown, PA 17576
Address: 200 Hartmann Bridge Road, Strasburg, PA 17579
Address: 1136 Arch Street, Philadelphia, PA 19107
Address: 2760 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird In Hand, PA 17505
Address: 300 E Main Street, Big Run, PA 15715
Address: 1899 Olde Mill Restaurant – 9 Queen Road, Intercourse, PA 17534
Address: 2855 Lincoln Hwy East, Ronks, PA 17572
The OIYS Visitor Center

best Amish restaurants in Pennsylvania

August 10, 2020
Elisa Regulski

What is there to do in Amish Country in Pennsylvania?

There are so many fun ways to experience the Amish Country in Pennsylvania. For starters, take a tour with Amish Experience at Plain & Fancy Farm. This unique experience is sure to be an adventure you’ll never forget. Tour the farmlands, visit a one-room schoolhouse, and spend time with an Amish family. If you want to shop for authentic Amish goods, visit Peaceful Valley Furniture. With several locations scattered throughout Pennsylvania, it’s never been easier to purchase some handcrafted and gorgeous pieces for your home.

What are the best comfort food restaurants in Pennsylvania?

Everyone loves a hearty plate of comfort food, and what’s more nostalgic than a bowl of mac and cheese? If this iconic dish brings back happy childhood memories, you’ll want to enjoy a meal at Mac Mart in Philadelphia. In addition to their classic mac and cheese options, this unique restaurant serves creative concoctions. Anyone up for BBQ mac and cheese? It’s incredible! For more comforting dishes, visit Hershey Pantry. Whether you visit for breakfast or lunch, you’ll be blown away by the terrific selection.

What kind of food are the Amish known for?

At most Amish restaurants, you’ll find comfort food classics like fried chicken, meat loaf, and mashed potatoes. But that’s not all the Amish are known for. Be sure to try some scrumptious scrapple and Dutch cabbage rolls. For dessert, enjoy classic dishes like shoofly pie and apple dumplings. Luckily, there are many Amish restaurants in Pennsylvania that have all-you-can-eat options. It’s the best way to try something new! Who knows? You may just discover your new favorite dish. Additionally, there are so many fantastic Amish bakeries in Pennsylvania. These lovely places boast incredible pastries, breads, and sweet treats. Bring your sweet tooth and indulge a little!

Address: 150 Eastbrook Road, Smoketown, PA 17576
Address: 200 Hartmann Bridge Road, Strasburg, PA 17579
Address: 1136 Arch Street, Philadelphia, PA 19107
Address: 2760 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird In Hand, PA 17505
Address: 300 E Main Street, Big Run, PA 15715
Address: 1899 Olde Mill Restaurant – 9 Queen Road, Intercourse, PA 17534
Address: 2855 Lincoln Hwy East, Ronks, PA 17572