The One Italian Restaurant Near Cincinnati With Pasta As Good As Grandma’s
No one cooks quite like Grandma, especially when it comes to comfort foods like good old pasta. But there’s a hidden gem near Cincinnati that will not only serve you some of the best pasta in the city, but you’ll feel welcomed and right at home. Stefano’s Italian Cafe in Middletown is a locally owned and lovingly operated restaurant that is a neighborhood favorite. It’s about time the rest of Cincinnati discovered this Italian gem with food so good, you’ll think Grandma made it herself.
Located just outside of Cincinnati in Middletown, Stefano's Italian Cafe has been a favorite dining spot for those in the area for years.
The restaurant started as a deli in 1989 and within a few years expanded to include a larger space for dining. Throughout the years, more additions have been made including more seating, a full service bar, and a lovely outdoor patio.
The interior has a warm and welcoming atmosphere and shows signs of growth over the past several years.
It definitely has a neighborhood cafe feel, with plenty of Italian flair. There are multiple seating areas, so you can choose from a brightly lit table, a cozy booth or, on a nice day, a seat on the patio.
Of course, the main attraction here is the incredible food.
The specials are also always worth a taste, as well as their authentic wood-fired pizza. The portions are great for the price and you can't beat the impeccable service.
Stefano's may be a local hit in Middletown, but it's a bit of a hidden gem for those living within the Cincinnati city limits.
So if you need a warm Italian meal that reminds you of what Grandma used to make, check out Stefano's Italian Cafe. The pasta - as well as the rest of the menu - will leave you feeling full, happy, and satisfied.
Stefano’s serves incredible pasta, buy everything on their menu is just as irresistible. Have you dined at this local gem? What’s your favorite Italian restaurant in the Cincinnati area? Let us know in the comments!
Stefano’s Italian Cafe is located at 2200 Central Ave. Middletown, Ohio 45044.
Looking for another wonderful Italian experience? Check out one of our other favorites in our recent article featuring a truly unique underground restaurant that also serves up a delightful taste of Italy.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Cincinnati In Your Inbox
Thank you! You'll receive your first newsletter soon!
A Cincinnati native who has lived in Kentucky for over 10 years, Andrea's heart belongs both in the Queen City and the Bluegrass State. After earning an education degree and working in that field for a number of years, Andrea began to pursue her passion for writing over 6 years ago. Since then she has written for a number of print and online publications, as well as published a children's book.
