12 Under The Radar Restaurants In New York That Are Scrumdiddlyumptious

In New York, our residents are quite possibly the best professional secret keepers you’ll ever come across. When it comes to certain beloved attractions within our state, you’ll almost literally have to pull our teeth to get our favorite spots out of us. With our mouths sealed tight and almost always full of delicious food, we’ve managed to keep these 12 restaurants under the radar that serve up dishes that are scrumdiddlyumptious.

Google Maps

Dave D/TripAdvisor

It may be the tasty beer that originally draws you in to this Brockport restaurant but it's the drool-worthy food menu that will always keep you coming back for more. Found just west of Rochester, the small town's brewery is right along the Erie Canal and features outdoor seating during our warmer months. From great deals on wings to Roc City Plate Bites and Poutine, you can view the Stoneyard's entire menu by clicking here.

How to get here: 1 Main Street Brockport, NY 14420

Clare D./Yelp

Clare D./Yelp

Nowadays you'll normally find pork or chicken inside of a Spiedie, but true New Yorkers know that the best kind of Spiedie is one that's filled with lamb. Down in our Southern Tier there's Lupo's, this restaurant is open every day of the week and is one of the only places in the Empire State where you can get a legitimate Spiedie that will knock your socks off. To find out more information and to view their classic menu, click here.

How to get here: 6 West State Street Binghamton, NY 13901

Steven F./Yelp

John W./Yelp

There are plenty of diners all over the Empire State that will quench your hunger, but there's one particular diner that you'll frequently hear our Upstate residents recommend. The Triangle Diner of Saratoga is a location that often goes under the radar to residents in the area yet also manages to keep a steady crowd of customers that can't stop returning to this place for the incredible food.

How to get here: 400 Maple Avenue Saratoga Springs, NY 12866

Marqus R./Yelp

Katie V./Yelp

Head out west toward to Cattaraugus County and you'll discover plenty of hidden treasures within the quaint city of Olean. Beef 'N' Barrel has a unique ambiance that you won't find anywhere else in the area, making you feel like you just walked into a family member's house who has your favorite home-cooked meal waiting for you back in the kitchen. To find out more information and to view their menu, click here.

How to get here: 146 North Union Street Olean, NY 14760

buster/TripAdvisor

S W./Yelp

To our residents that are up north in the city of Plattsburgh and can't figure out what to eat, we have the solution you've been searching for. A cozy restaurant that showcases homemade dishes that will make you wish you had room for more, this is the perfect place to come when you're craving a good breakfast.

How to get here: 2 Big Hank Plaza Road Plattsburgh, NY 12901

Google Maps

Rick H./Yelp

The perfect place to dine at before you take on the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, Halsey's is open every day of the week except for Monday's. You won't have any issues finding something to pick off of their menu, from wood fired pizza and meatballs to gourmet burgers that look too good to be true they have it all. To find out more information and to see what other delectable dishes can be found on their menu, click here.

How to get here: 106 Seneca Street Geneva, NY 14456

Johnny P./Yelp

Mel B./Yelp

Visit the beautiful but small town of Naples to discover what stunning beauty and unbelievable flavors can be found out in the Finger Lakes. Made up of quirky characteristics that you'll find yourself attracted to, the café has a menu full of homemade dishes that you'll wish you could feast on every single night.

How to get here: 197 North Main Street Naples, NY 14512

Chicken Run Family Restaurant and Steak House/Yelp

Jiaxin D./Yelp

Out along Route 23 in the Catskills you'll find a variety of attractions that will make you stop and pull over, one of them being the Chicken Run restaurant. A gorgeous establishment to check out during the warmer months when you can enjoy yourself outside around their fire pit, Chicken Run offers a welcoming ambiance inside that will keep you pleased during the colder seasons. With dishes that will fill you up to the brim, you can find out more information and view their tasty menus by clicking here.

How to get here: 5639 State Route 23 Windham, NY 12496

Charles J./Yelp

Jess M./Yelp

Come out to Long Island if you're looking to pair up your meal with the milkshake of a lifetime. There's no denying that you'll enjoy all of the classic dishes that you'll find on this diner's menu, but you certainly can't leave this place without trying one of their vibrant and whimsical milkshakes. Filled with color and usually even toys, this delicious treat is one you'll be recommending to all of your friends as soon as it hits your lips.

How to get here: 260 East Park Avenue Long Beach, NY 11561

Taylor O./Yelp

Mandy R./Yelp

Bringing to you your favorite diner dishes with a unique flare, Shorty's is a family-owned business that's been operating in Watertown for over ten years now. Out by Lake Ontario, you'll find that there are quite a few gems hiding up in this area of New York. Serving breakfast all day and known for their flavorful milkshakes, you can find out more information and view their entire menu by clicking here.

How to get here: 1280 Coffeen Street Watertown, NY 13601

Mckenzie's Grille/Facebook

Krista M./Yelp

A long-time local favorite, this Adirondack restaurant continues to win over guests with its spectacular family-style menu items. You're more than welcome to get lunch here, but it's the breakfast dishes that are served here that will have your stomach rumbling in the best way possible. Try their unforgettable pancakes (you can never go wrong with Blueberry) or anything else that's offered on the menu, you simply can't go wrong with any of it! Open from 6AM to 2PM, you can find out more information by clicking here.

How to get here: 477 Lake Flower Avenue Saranac Lake, NY 12983

Chris B./Yelp

Michelle B./Yelp

A place that will become your new favorite restaurant to grab a pizza on Long Island, Blue Moon of Rockville Centre provides its customers with fine Italian food that will have your taste buds forever thanking you. Family recipes that haven't changed with time, the restaurant has been a favorite for more than 60 years. To view their mouthwatering menu and to find out more information, click here.

How to get here: 26 North Park Avenue Rockville Centre, NY 11570

Do you have a favorite underrated restaurant that you would’ve liked to have seen on this list? If you’re feeling like you want to jump out of bed and avoid the kitchen, head to any one of these 11 Amazing Breakfast Spots In New York That Will Make Your Morning Just Right!