Grilled cheese sandwiches are one of the most popular comfort foods, and it’s really no wonder why. Basic American cheese on plain white bread? Delicious. A more complicated melt involving meats, veggies, gourmet bread, and fancy cheeses? Still delicious. This is a dish that can delight just about anybody. One restaurant that serves up grilled cheese sandwiches in New York better than practically anywhere else is Buffalo Melting Point. This ivy-clad eatery primarily specializes in a single dish, but they serve it so well (and in so many varieties!) that you have virtually endless options to choose from.

This hidden gem in New York is tucked away behind a beautiful wall of ivy. It's a little small, but the menu is surprisingly expansive for a grilled cheese sandwich restaurant.
Skillz Mitchell/Google Maps
No matter how fancy or simple you want to go, there's an option here for you. If you're a purist, there are cheese-only options, but there are also plenty of toppings if you want to get a little more complex.
Buffalo Melting Point
Bacon, chicken, corned beef, caramelized onions, even kimchi: be aware, there are so many toppings here that you may have trouble deciding!
Buffalo Melting Point

Related Stories

This Restaurant In A Former New York Post Office Offers An Unforgettable Dining Experience

This Restaurant In A Former New York Post Office Offers An Unforgettable Dining Experience

 The Old-World Diner In New York Where You’ll Find All Sorts Of Hearty Eats

The Old-World Diner In New York Where You’ll Find All Sorts Of Hearty Eats

 You Must Taste A Spiedie At This Unique Sandwich Restaurant In New York

You Must Taste A Spiedie At This Unique Sandwich Restaurant In New York
Pairing your grilled cheese sandwich with a soup is virtually a necessity, especially on a cool day. Tomato basil is their specialty, but they change up the homemade soup options regularly, so you won't get bored.
Buffalo Melting Point/Google Maps
Even the condiments here are made from scratch. Everything is locally-procured when possible using the highest quality ingredients.
Akshay SG/Google Maps
One trip here and you certainly won't be thinking of grilled cheese sandwiches as a kiddie food any more!
Jessica Henderson/Google Maps

For more information about Buffalo Melting Point, including a menu, check out their website.

Have you visited this delicious grilled cheese restaurant in New York? Or do you have another suggestion for best grilled cheese sandwich in New York? Share your thoughts in the comments!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore New York

Featured Addresses
Buffalo Melting Point, 244 Allen St, Buffalo, NY 14201, USA